18
Excursus on the Rise of the Patriarchate of Jerusalem.
The narrative of the successive steps by which the See of Jerusalem rose from being
nothing but Ælia, a Gentile city, into one of the five patriarchal sees is sad reading for a
Christian. It is but the record of ambition and, worse still, of knavery. No Christian can
for a moment grudge to the Holy City of the old dispensation the honour shewn it by the
Church, but he may well wish that the honour had been otherwise obtained. A careful study
of such records as we possess shews that until the fifth century the Metropolitan of Cæsarea
as often took precedence of the Bishop of Jerusalem as vice versa, and Beveridge has taken
great pains to shew that the learned De Marca is in error in supposing that the Council of
Nice assigned to Jerusalem a dignity superior to Cæsarea, and only inferior to Rome, Alex-
andria, and Antioch. It is true that in the signatures the Bishop of Jerusalem does sign before
his metropolitan, but to this Beveridge justly replies that the same is the case with the occu-
pants of two other of his suffragan sees. Bishop Beveridge’s opinion is that the Council as-
signed Jerusalem the second place in the province, such as London enjoys in the Province
of Canterbury. This, however, would seem to be as much too little as De Marca’s contention
grants too much. It is certain that almost immediately after the Council had adjourned, the
Bishop of Jerusalem, Maximus, convoked a synod of Palestine, without any reference to
Cæsarea, which consecrated bishops and acquitted St. Athanasius. It is true that he was
reprimanded for doing so,67 but yet it clearly shews how he intended to understand the action
of Nice. The matter was not decided for a century more, and then through the chicanery
of Juvenal the bishop of Jerusalem.
(Canon Venables, Dict. Christ. Biography.)
Juvenalis succeeded Praylius as bishop of Jerusalem somewhere about 420 a.d. The
exact year cannot be determined. The episcopate of Praylius, which commenced in 417
a.d., was but short, and we can hardly give it at most more than three years. The statement
of Cyril of Scythopolis, in his Life of St. Euthymius (c. 96), that Juvenal died “in the forty-
fourth year of his episcopate,” 458 a.d., is certainly incorrect, as it would make his episcopate
begin in 414 a.d., three years before that of his predecessor. Juvenal occupies a prominent
position during the Nestorian and Eutychian troubles towards the middle of the fifth century.
But the part played by him at the councils of Ephesus and Chalcedon, as well as at the dis-
graceful λῃστρικὴ σύνοδος of 449, was more conspicuous than creditable, and there are few
of the actors in these turbulent and saddening scenes who leave a more unpleasing impres-
sion. The ruling object of Juvenal’s episcopate, to which everything else was secondary, and
which guided all his conduct, was the elevation of the see of Jerusalem from the subordinate
position it held in accordance with the seventh of the canons of the council of Nicæa, as
suffragan to the metropolitan see of Cæsarea, to a primary place in the episcopate. Not
67 Socrates: Hist. Eccl., ii. 24.
Excursus on the Rise of the Patriarchate of Jerusalem.
68
Excursus on the Rise of the Patriarchate of Jerusalem.