by them in that struggle in every place are attested by the existing traces of events so recent.
Documents declare the orders given. The deeds done are notorious throughout regions in
which also the sacred memory of your leader Optatus is mentioned with honour.
4. Again, you are wont to say that we have not the baptism of Christ, and that beyond
your communion it is not to be found. On this I would enter into a more lengthened argu-
ment; but in dealing with you this is not necessary, seeing that, along with Felicianus and
Prætextatus, you admitted also the baptism of the Maximianists as valid. For all whom these
bishops baptized so long as they were in communion with Maximianus, while you were
doing your utmost in a protracted contest in the civil courts to expel these very men [Feli-
cianus and Prætextatus] from their churches, as the Acts testify,—all those, I say, whom
they baptized during that time, they now have in fellowship with them and with you; and
though these were baptized by them when excommunicated and in the guilt of schism, not
only in cases of extremity through dangerous sickness, but also at the Easter services, in the
large number of churches belonging to their cities, and in these important cities them-
selves,—in the case of none of them has the rite of baptism been repeated. And I wish you
could prove that those whom Felicianus and Prætextatus had baptized, as it were, in vain,
when they were excommunicated and in the guilt of schism, were satisfactorily baptized
again by them when they were restored. For if the renewal of baptism was necessary for the
people, the renewal of ordination was not less necessary for the bishops. For they had forfeited
their episcopal office by leaving you, if they could not baptize beyond your communion;
because, if they had not forfeited their episcopal office by leaving you, they could still baptize.
But if they had forfeited their episcopal office, they should have received ordination when
they returned, so that what they had lost might be restored. Let not this, however, alarm
you. As it is certain that they returned with the same standing as bishops with which they
had gone forth from you, so is it also certain that they brought back with themselves to your
communion, without any repetition of their baptism, all those whom they had baptized in
the schism of Maximianus.
5. How can we weep enough when we see the baptism of the Maximianists acknowledged
by you, and the baptism of the Church universal despised? Whether it was with or without
hearing their defence, whether it was justly or unjustly, that you condemned Felicianus and
Prætextatus, I do not ask; but tell me what bishop of the Corinthian Church ever defended
himself at your bar, or received sentence from you? or what bishop of the Galatians has
done so, or of the Ephesians, Colossians, Philippians, Thessalonians, or of any of the other
cities included in the promise: “All the kindreds of the nations shall worship before Thee”?1703
Yet you accept the baptism of the former, while that of the latter is despised; whereas baptism
belongs neither to the one nor to the other, but to Him of whom it was said: “This same is
1703 Ps. xxii. 27.
673
To Crispinus