144 ON THE TRINITY. [bOOK IV.
name voepov), not certainly so as to form one person (for
who could possibly say that whatever creature it was by
which the voice of the Father sounded, is in such sense
God the Father ; or whatever creature it was by which the
Holy Spirit was manifested in the form of a dove, or in fiery
tongues, is in such sense the Holy Spirit, as the Son of God
is that man who was made of a virgin ?), but only to the
ministry of bringing about such intimations as God judged
needful ; or whether anything else is to be understood : is
difficult to discover, and not expedient rashly to affirm. Yet
I see not how those things could have been brought to pass
without the rational or intellectual creature. But it is not
yet the proper place to explain, as the Lord may give me
strength, why I so think ; for the arguments of heretics must
first be discussed and refuted, which they do not produce from
the divine books, but from their own reasons, and by which,
as they think, they forcibly compel us so to understand the
testimonies of the Scriptures which treat of the Father, and
the Son, and the Holy Spirit, as they themselves will.
32. But now, as I think, it has been sufficiently shown, that
the Son is not therefore less because He is sent by the Father,
nor the Holy Spirit less because both the Father sentHim and
the Son. For these things are perceived to be laid down in
the Scriptures, either on account of the visible creature, or
rather on account of commending to our thoughts the principle
[of the Godhead], but not on account of inequality, or im-
parity, or unlikeness of substance ; since, even if God the
Father had willed to appear visibly through the subject
creature, yet it would be most absurd to say that He was sent
either by the Son,whom He begot, or by the Holy Spirit, who
proceeds from Him. Let this, therefore, be the limit of the
present book. Henceforth in the rest we shall see, the Lord
helping, of what sort are those crafty arguments of the heretics,
and in what manner they may be confuted.