X. Whereas, in p. 16. of my book, I observed it to be the opinion of some, that “Although
the members of the visible church are saints in profession and visibility, and in the acceptance
of others, yet this is not with reference to saving holiness, but quite another sort of saintship,
viz. moral sincerity; and that this is the real saintship, discipleship, and godliness, that is
professed and visible in them,” &c. Mr. W. (p. 4, 5.) says, He does not remember that he
ever heard of this, or that anybody thought of it, before he saw it in my book; and represents
it as a poor man of straw, of my own framing; and he insists upon it, that it is allowed on all
hands, that the visibility must be with reference to saving holiness.
I will not say, that Mr. W. knew it to be a false representation which he here makes; but
this I will say, that he ought to have been better informed, before he had thus publicly ri-
diculed this as a fiction of mine; especially considering the opportunities and advantages he
has had to know otherwise: this being the notion that had been (as was before observed) so
loudly and publicly insisted on, for more than two years, by the people of Northampton,
and by the neighbouring ministers, and those of them that were Mr. W.‘s near relatives; as
he has abundant opportunities to be fully informed, having withal had great inducements
to inquire. Besides, that this has been the universal opinion of all that part of the country
(who thought themselves Mr. Stoddard’s followers) for more than twenty years, is a fact as
notorious, as that the people there generally believe Mr. Stoddard’s doctrine of the necessity
of a work of conversion in order to get to heaven.—And this is the opinion professedly
maintained in a pamphlet published in Boston, (anno 1741,) entitled, A Right to the Lord’s
Supper considered: a piece which has long been well known among Mr. W.’s nearest relatives,
and in good repute with them; as I have had occasion to observe. This pamphlet insists ex-
pressly and abundantly, that moral sincerity is the REAL discipleship and holiness, with respect
to which visible Christians are called disciples and saints in Scripture. Particularly see pages
9, 10, 13, and 14. And which is more strange yet, Mr. Blake, the great author Mr. W. makes
so much use of, and in a book which I know he has long been the possessor of, speaks much
of a profession of religion that has respect only to a dogmatical, historical faith, a common
faith, a faith true indeed (as he says) in its kind, but short of that which is justifying and
saving, and a profession which goes no further, as that which entitles to sealing ordinances.
See Blake on the Covenant, p. 241, 244, 245. The same author again and again distinguishes
between justifying faith and faith of profession; as in p. 284, 285, 286. And which is more
than all this, Mr. W. (as will appear in the sequel) abundantly contends for the same thing
himself, though against himself, and although he charges me (p. 35.d.) with a great misrep-
resentation, in supposing that according to the scheme of my opposers, the profession re-
quired in those that are admitted, does not imply a pretence to any thing more than moral
sincerity and common grace.
1912
SECTION II. Degrees of evidence.