Chapter
XVIII.—
The Works of Justin which have
come down to us.
1.
This
writer has left us a great many monuments of a mind educated and
practiced in divine things, which are replete with profitable matter of
every kind. To them we shall refer the studious, noting as we proceed
those that have come to our knowledge.
1192
2. There is a certain
discourse
1193
of his in defense of our doctrine
addressed to Antoninus surnamed the Pious, and to his sons, and to the
Roman senate. Another work contains his second Apology
1194
in behalf of our faith, which he offered
to him who was the successor of the emperor mentioned and who bore the
same name, Antoninus Verus, the one whose times we are now
recording.
3. Also another work against the
Greeks,
1195
in which he discourses at length upon
most of the questions at issue between us and the Greek philosophers,
and discusses the nature of demons. It is not necessary for me to add
any of these things here.
4. And still another work of his
against the Greeks has come down to us, to which he gave the title
Refutation. And besides these another, On the Sovereignty of God,
1196
which he establishes not only from our
Scriptures, but also from the books of the Greeks.
5. Still further, a work
entitled Psaltes,
1197
and another
disputation On the Soul, in which, after propounding various questions
concerning the problem under discussion, he gives the opinions of the
Greek philosophers, promising to refute it, and to present his own view
in another work.
6. He composed also a dialogue
against the Jews,
1198
which he held
in the city of Ephesus with Trypho, a most distinguished man among the
Hebrews of that day. In it he shows how the divine grace urged him on
to the doctrine of the faith, and with what earnestness he had formerly
pursued philosophical studies, and how ardent a search he had made for
the truth.
1199
7. And he records of the Jews in
the same work, that they were plotting against the teaching of Christ,
asserting the
same things against Trypho: “Not only did you not repent of
the wickedness which you had committed, but you selected at that time
chosen men, and you sent them out from Jerusalem through all the land,
to announce that the godless heresy of the Christians had made its
appearance, and to accuse them of those things which all that are
ignorant of us say against us, so that you become the causes not only
of your own injustice, but also of all other men’s.”
1200
8. He writes also that even down
to his time prophetic gifts shone in the Church.
1201
And he mentions the Apocalypse of John,
saying distinctly that it was the apostle’s.
1202
He also refers to certain prophetic
declarations, and accuses Trypho on the ground that the Jews had cut
them out of the Scripture.
1203
A great many
other works of his are still in the hands of many of the brethren.
1204
9. And the discourses of the man
were thought so worthy of study even by the ancients, that Irenæus
quotes his words: for instance, in the fourth book of his work Against
Heresies, where he writes as follows:
1205
“And Justin well says in his work against Marcion, that he would
not have believed the Lord himself if he had preached another God
besides the Creator”; and again in the fifth book of the same
work he says:
1206
“And Justin
well said that before the coming of the Lord Satan never dared to
blaspheme God,
1207
because he did
not yet know his condemnation.”
10. These things I have deemed
it necessary to say for the sake of stimulating the studious to peruse
his works with diligence. So much concerning him.
1192
Eusebius apparently cites here only the works which he had himself
seen, which accounts for his omission of the work against Marcion
mentioned above, in chap. 11.
1193
This
Apology
is the genuine work of Justin, and is still
extant in two late and very faulty
mss.
, in
which it is divided into two, and the parts are commonly known as
Justin’s First and Second Apologies, though they were originally
one. The best edition of the original is that of Otto in his
Corpus
Apologetarum Christianorum;
English translation in the
Ante-Nicene Fathers,
Vol. I. p. 163 ff. Eusebius, in his
Chronicle,
places the date of its composition as 141, but most
critics are now agreed in putting it ten or more years later; it must,
however, have been written before the death of Antoninus Pius (161).
See Schaff,
Ch. Hist.
II. p. 716.
1194
Eusebius here, as in chap. 16 above, ascribes to Justin a second
Apology, from which, however, he nowhere quotes. From Eusebius the
tradition has come down through history that Justin wrote two
apologies, and the tradition seems to be confirmed by the existing
mss.
of Justin, which give two. But
Eusebius’ two cannot have corresponded to the present two; for,
from chap. 8, §§16 and 17, it is plain that to Eusebius our
two formed one complete work. And it is plain, too, from internal
evidence (as is now very generally admitted; Wieseler’s arguments
against this, in his
Christenverfolgungen,
p. 104 ff., are not
sound), that the two were originally one, our second forming simply a
supplement to the first. What, then, has become of the second Apology
mentioned by Eusebius? There is much difference of opinion upon this
point. But the explanation given by Harnack (p. 171 ff.) seems the most
probable one. According to his theory, the Apology of Athenagoras (of
whom none of the Fathers, except Methodius and Philip of Side, seem to
have had any knowledge) was attributed to Justin by a copyist of the
third century,—who altered the address so as to throw it into
Justin’s time,—and as such it came into the hands of
Eusebius, who mentions it among the works of Justin. That he does not
quote from it may be due to the fact that it contained nothing suited
to his purpose, or it is possible that he had some suspicions about it;
the last, however, is not probable, as he nowhere hints at them. That
some uncertainty, however, seemed to hang about the work is evident.
The erasure of the name of Athenagoras and the substitution of
Justin’s name accounts for the almost total disappearance of the
former from history. This Apology and his treatise on the resurrection
first appear again under his name in the eleventh century, and exist
now in seventeen
mss.
(see Schaff, II. 731).
The traditional second Apology of Justin having thus after the eleventh
century disappeared, his one genuine Apology was divided by later
copyists, so that we still have apparently two separate
apologies.
1195
This
and the following were possibly genuine works of Justin; but, as they
are no longer extant, it is impossible to speak with certainty. The two
extant works,
Discourse to the Greeks (Oratio ad Græcos)
and
Hortatory Address to the Greeks (Cohortatio ad Græcos),
which are translated in the
Ante-Nicene Fathers,
I. p.
271–289, are to be regarded as the productions of later writers,
and are not to be identified with the two mentioned here (although Otto
defends them both, and Semisch defends the latter).
1196
We
have no reason to think that this work was not genuine, but it is no
longer extant, and therefore certainty in the matter is impossible. It
is not to be identified with the extant work upon the same subject
(translated in the
Ante-Nicene Fathers,
I. p. 290–293),
which is the production of a later writer.
1197
This work and the following have entirely disappeared, but were
genuine productions of Justin, for all that we know to the
contrary.
1198
This is a genuine work of Justin, and is still extant (translated
in the
Ante-Nicene Fathers,
I. p. 194–270). Its exact date
is uncertain, but it was written after the
Apology
(to which it
refers in chap. 120), and during the reign of Antoninus Pius
(137–161).
Of Trypho, whom Eusebius
characterizes as “a most distinguished man among the
Hebrews,” we know nothing beyond what we can gather from the
dialogue itself.
1199
See
Dial.
chap. 2 sq.
1200
ibid.
chap. 17.
1201
ibid.
chap. 82.
1202
ibid.
chap. 81.
1203
ibid.
chap. 71.
1204
Of
the many extant and non-extant works attributed to Justin by tradition,
all, or the most of them (except the seven mentioned by Eusebius, and
the work
Against Marcion,
quoted by Irenæus,—see just
below,—and the
Syntagma Contra omnes Hær.
), are the
productions of later writers.
1205
Irenæus,
Adv. Hær.
IV. 6. 2.
1206
Irenæus, V. 26. 2. Irenæus does not name the work which
he quotes here, and the quotation occurs in none of Justin’s
extant works, but the context and the sense of the quotation itself
seem to point to the same work,
Against Marcion.
1207
Epiphanius expresses the same thought in his
Hær
.
XXXIX. 9.