serve to prepare the way for a more easy, short, and intelligible answer to your remaining
queries.
Quest. IV. Whether it be the general opinion of protestant churches and divines, in the
case of adult persons, that the terms of admission to both sacraments are the same?
ANSW. I presume, Sir, the question does not respect a sameness in the degree of quali-
483
fications, experiences, and evidences; but only a sameness in kind, or for the substance and
general nature of things. I suppose, you had no view here to any such critical distinction as
that before mentioned, between an initial faith and a grown faith; or between the simple
being of faith, which entitleth to baptism, and the special exercise of faith, which fits for the
Lord’s supper; nor aim at a nice adjustment of the several characters of visibility, or motives
of credibility, in the one case and the other, but only intend in general to inquire, whether
persons admittable to one or other sacrament, ought to profess true justifying faith, and not
be admitted on the profession of any faith of a kind inferior and specifically different. Now,
taking this to be the scope of your question, I have good reason to apprehend, that the gen-
erality of protestant churches and divines, of the Calvinistic persuasion especially, have de-
clared themselves for the affirmative.
I think all that hold the visible christian church ought to consist of such as make a visible
and credible profession of faith and holiness, and appear to rational charity real members of
the church invisible, (which is the common language of protestants,) are to be understood
as in principle exploding the conceit of a conscious unbeliever’s right before God to special
church-ordinances, and as denying the apparent unbeliever’s right before the church to
admission, whether to one sacrament or the other. I observe, Eadem est ratio utriusque
sacramenti, is a maxim (in its general notion) espoused by the several contending parties
in this controversy about a right to sacraments.
That a credible profession of saving faith and repentance is necessary to baptism, in the
case of the adult, I can show, by the authority of Claude’s approved Defence of the Reforma-
tion, to be the general opinion of French protestants; and by the Palatine Catechism, by the
Leyden Professors’ Synopsis, &c. to be the prevailing judgment of the reformed in Germany,
Holland, and foreign parts.
And for the Dissenters in England, that they are in general of the same judgment, I might
prove from the Assembly of Divines’ Confession, Catechisms, and Directory; and from the
Heads of Agreement assented to by the United Ministers, formerly distinguished by the
names of Presbyterian and Congregational; as also by a large induction of particular instances
among divines of every denomination, would it not carry me to too great a length. I find
Mr. Lob (in his True Dissenter) assuring us in general, “It is held by the dissenters, that
nothing less than the profession of a saving faith gives a right to baptism.“ Nor do I see, by
their writings of a later date and most in vogue, any just grounds to suppose a general change
of sentiments among them. I will mention two or three moderns of distinguished name.
1888
Appendix. Mr. Foxcroft's letter.