172 MEMORIALS OF TWO SISTERS [1857-8
united certainty. That, however, may be the fault of my
Evangelical up-bringing and heretical associations. Then
I have a great fear of confounding mere " notions and
views" with those deep truths which are arrived at by
personal experience; and sometimes when "private judg-
ment
"
is spoken against, it seems not to be distinguished
from what is in truth different enough the inner Light
which I believe lighteth every man, and reveals to humble
and prayerful hearts whatever is necessary to their salva-
tion. No truth can be received profitably on any outward
authority alone; until it has this inner witness it is not
really known, and does not rule the soul and heart. I
suppose it comes to this : you speak as if there were but
two means of arriving at truth mere human reasoning,
or the outward authority of the Church, giving us notions
and views, or a complete body of doctrine. And I think
this leaves out the grand method by which truth comes to
us namely, that the Spirit shows it to those who do the
will of the Father; sometimes through the Church, but
often directly in the heart without the intervention of any
creature. Such truth is confirmed by the outward witness,
but cannot be given by that alone. Also, we only see bits
of the Truth at a time ; to us it is ever growing, and can
never be complete and entirely systematic ; therefore we
must always be ready to see the different aspects of
truth which may be hidden under some one else's apparent
error.
CATHERINE to EMILY
ALDERLEY EDGE, Nov. 1st, 1857.
On Thursday evening I went to the Concert Hall to
hear Beethoven's pth Symphony, the grand choral one.
It was a great triumph for Mr. Halle to get it up, for it is
only the second time it has ever been given in England.
The symphony itself seemed to me quite as grand as I
remembered it when we heard it in Dresden, but the per-
formance not equal to that. The parts were not so well
blended, and the voices were especially deficient in force.