circumstances, to love God: but yet it is not a duty to love God without loving him, or con-
tinuing without those things that essentially belong to his love. It is the duty of those that
have no sense of the loveliness of God, and have no esteem of him, to love him, and they be
not in the least excused by the want of this sense and esteem, in not loving him one moment;
but yet it would be properly nonsense to say it is their duty to love him without any sense
of his loveliness or any esteem of him. It is indeed their duty this moment to come out of
their disesteem and stupid wicked insensibility of his loveliness, and to love him. I made
the distinction (I thought) very plainly, in the midst of those sentences you quote as excep-
tionable. I say expressly, p. 74. “It is truly the duty of those who are in darkness to come out
of darkness into light and believe; but, that they should confidently believe and trust, while
they yet remain without spiritual light or sight, is an anti-scriptural and absurd doctrine.”
The misunderstanding between us, dear Sir, I suppose to be in the different application of
the particle without, in my use of it, and your understanding of it, or what we understand
as spoken of and supposed in the expression, without spiritual light or sight. As I use it, I
apply it to the act of believing, and I suppose it to be very absurd to talk of an act of faith
without spiritual light and sight, wherein I suppose you will allow me to be in the right. As
you understand it, it is applied to duty or obligation, and you suppose it to be not at all absurd
to talk of an obligation to believe without spiritual light or sight, but that the obligation re-
mains full where there is no spiritual light or sight, wherein I allow you are in the right. I
think, Sir, if you read what I have said in my book on this head again, it will be exceeding
apparent to you, that it is thus that I apply the preposition without, and not as you before
understood it. I thought I had very plainly manifested that what I meant by being in darkness
was a being in spiritual blindness, and so in a dead, stupid, carnal, and unchristian frame
and way, and not what is commonly called a being without the light of God’s countenance,
under the hidings of his face. We have a great number of people in these parts that go on
that supposition in their notions and practice, that there really is such a thing as such a
manner of believing, such a kind of faith as this, viz. a confident believing and firm trusting
in God in the dark, in the sense mentioned, that is to be sought after, and is “the subject
matter of divine prescription, and which many actually have; and indeed there are innumer-
able instances of such as are apparently in a most senseless, careless, negligent, apostate,
and every way unchristian and wicked frame, that yet, encouraged by this principle, do retain
an exceeding strong confidence of their good state, and count that herein they do their duty
and give much glory to God, under the notion of trusting God in the dark, and hoping
against hope, and not trusting on their own righteousness; and they suppose it would show
a legal spirit to do otherwise. I thought it would be manifest to every reader that I was arguing
against such a sort of people.
You say, “It merits consideration whether the believer should ever doubt of his state,
on any account whatever, because doubting, as opposed to believing, is absolutely sinful.”
1483
LETTER I. To Mr. Gillespie, in answer to objections.