296
Letter LI.
(a.d. 399 or 400.)
An invitation to Crispinus, Donatist bishop at Calama, to discuss the whole question
of the Donatist schism.
(No salutation at the beginning of the letter.)
1. I have adopted this plan in regard to the heading of this letter, because your party are
offended by the humility which I have shown in the salutations prefixed to others. I might
be supposed to have done it as an insult to you, were it not that I trust that you will do the
same in your reply to me. Why should I say much regarding your promise at Carthage, and
my urgency to have it fulfilled? Let the manner in which we then acted to each other be
forgotten with the past, lest it should obstruct future conference. Now, unless I am mistaken,
there is, by the Lord’s help, no obstacle in the way: we are both in Numidia, and located at
no great distance from each other. I have heard it said that you are still willing to examine,
in debate with me, the question which separates us from communion with each other. See
how promptly all ambiguities may be cleared away: send me an answer to this letter if you
please, and perhaps that may be enough, not only for us, but for those also who desire to
hear us; or if it is not, let us exchange letters again and again until the discussion is exhausted.
For what greater benefit could be secured to us by the comparative nearness of the towns
which we inhabit? I have resolved to debate with you in no other way than by letters, in order
both to prevent anything that is said from escaping from our memory, and to secure that
others interested in the question, but unable to be present at a debate, may not forfeit the
instruction. You are accustomed, not with any intention of falsehood, but by mistake, to
reproach us with charges such as may suit your purpose, concerning past transactions, which
we repudiate as untrue. Therefore, if you please, let us weigh the question in the light of the
present, and let the past alone. You are doubtless aware that in the Jewish dispensation the
sin of idolatry was committed by the people, and once the book of the prophet of God was
burned by a defiant king;1699 the punishment of the sin of schism would not have been
more severe than that with which these two were visited, had not the guilt of it been greater.
You remember, of course, how the earth opening swallowed up alive the leaders of a schism,
and fire from heaven breaking forth destroyed their accomplices.1700 Neither the making
and worshipping of an idol, nor the burning of the Holy Book, was deemed worthy of such
punishment.
2. You are wont to reproach us with a crime, not proved against us, indeed, though
proved beyond question against some of your own party,—the crime, namely, of yielding
up, through fear of persecution, the Scriptures1701 to be burned. Let me ask, therefore, why
1699 Jer. xxxvi. 23.
1700 Num. xvi. 31–35.
1701 Dominici libri.
To Crispinus
671
To Crispinus