508
dispensed to me by this hand, that I have neither before nor since my marriage been guilty
of immoral self-indulgence.”2653
10. What evil, then, was brought to him by death? Nay, rather, was it not the occasion
of the greatest possible good to him, because, in the possession of these gifts, he departed
from this life to Christ, in whom alone they are really possessed? I would not mention these
things in addressing you if I believed that you would be offended by my praising him. But
assuredly, as I do not believe this, neither do I believe that his being put to death was even
according to your desire or wish, much less that it was done at your request. You, therefore,
with a sincerity proportioned to your innocence in this matter, entertain, doubtless, along
with us, the opinion that the man who put him to death inflicted more cruel wrong on his
own soul than on the sufferer’s body, when, in despite of us, in despite of his own promises,
in despite of so many supplications and warnings from you, and finally, in despite of the
Church of Christ (and in her of Christ Himself), he consummated his base machinations
by putting this man to death. Is the high position of the one worthy to be compared with
the lot of the other, prisoner though he was, when the man of power was maddened by anger,
while the sufferer in his prison was filled with joy? There is nothing in all the dungeons of
this world, nay, not even in hell itself, to surpass the dreadful doom of darkness to which a
villian is consigned by remorse of conscience. Even to yourself, what evil did he do? He did
not destroy your innocence, although he grievously injured your reputation; which, never-
theless, remains uninjured, both in the estimation of those who know you better than we
do, and in our estimation, in whose presence the anxiety which, like us, you felt for the
prevention of such a monstrous crime, was expressed with so much visible agitation that
we could almost see with our eyes the invisible workings of your heart. Whatever harm,
therefore, he has done, he has done to himself alone; he has pierced through his own soul,
his own life, his own conscience; in fine, he has by that blind deed of cruelty destroyed even
his own good name, a thing which the very worst of men are usually fain to preserve. For
to all good men he is odious in proportion to his efforts to obtain, or his satisfaction in re-
ceiving, the approbation of the wicked.
11. Could anything prove more clearly that he was not under the necessity which he
pretended—alleging that he did this evil action as a good man who had no alternative—than
the fact that the proceeding was disapproved of by the person whose orders he dared to
plead as his excuse? The pious deacon by whose hand we send this was himself associated
with the bishop whom we had sent to intercede for them; let him, therefore, relate to your
Excellency how it seemed good to the Emperor not even to give a formal pardon, lest by
this the stigma of a crime should be in some degree attached to them, but a mere notice
commanding them to be immediately set at liberty from all further annoyance. By a purely
2653 Me nullum esse expertum concubitum præter uxorem.
1086
To Cæcilianus