Chapter XX.—The Writings of Irenæus against the Schismatics at Rome.
1. Irenæus1661 wrote several letters against those who were disturbing the sound ordin-
238
ance of the Church at Rome. One of them was to Blastus On Schism;1662 another to Florinus
On Monarchy,1663 or That God is not the Author of Evil. For Florinus seemed to be defending
this opinion. And because he was being drawn away by the error of Valentinus, Irenæus
1661 On Irenæus, see Bk. IV. chap. 21, note 9.
1662 Eusebius, in chap. 15, informs us that both Blastus and Florinus drew many away from the church of
Rome by their heretical innovations. He does not tell us either there or here the nature of the opinions which
Blastus held, but from Pseudo-Tertullian’s Adv. omnes Hær. chap. 8, we learn that Blastus was a Quartodeciman.
(“In addition to all these, there is likewise Blastus, who would latently introduce Judaism. For he says the pas-
sover is not to be kept otherwise than according to the law of Moses, on the fourteenth of the month.”) From
Pacianus’ Epistola ad Sympronian. de catholico nomine, chap. 2, we learn that he was a Montanist; and since the
Montanists of Asia Minor were, like the other Christians of that region, Quartodecimans, it is not surprising
that Blastus should be at the same time a Montanist and a Quartodeciman. Florinus, as will be shown in the
next note, taught his heresies while Victor was bishop of Rome (189–198 or 199); and since Eusebius connects
Blastus so closely with him, we may conclude that Blastus flourished at about the same time. Irenæus’ epistle to
Blastus, On Schism, is no longer extant. A Syriac fragment of an epistle of Irenæus, addressed to “an Alexandrian,”
on the paschal question (Fragment 27 in Harvey’s edition) is possibly a part of this lost epistle. If the one referred
to in this fragment be Blastus, he was an Alexandrian, and in that case must have adopted the Quartodeciman
position under the influence of the Asiatic Montanists, for the paschal calendar of the Alexandrian church was
the same as that of Rome (see the Dict. of Christ. Biog. III. p. 264). If Blastus was a Montanist, as stated by Pacianus,
his heresy was quite different from that of Florinus (who was a Gnostic); and the fact that they were leaders of
different heresies is confirmed by the words of Eusebius in chap. 15, above: “Each one striving to introduce his
own innovations in respect to the truth.” Whether Blastus, like Florinus, was a presbyter, and like him was deposed
from his office, we do not know, but the words of Eusebius in chap. 15 seem to favor this supposition.
1663 Florinus, as we learn from chap. 15, was for a time a presbyter of the Roman Church, but lost his office
on account of heresy. From the fragment of this epistle of Irenæus to Florinus quoted by Eusebius just below,
we learn that Florinus was somewhat older than Irenæus, but like him a disciple of Polycarp. The title of this
epistle shows that Florinus was already a Gnostic, or at least inclined toward Gnostic views. Eusebius evidently
had no direct knowledge of the opinions of Florinus on the origin of evil, for he says that he appeared to maintain
(ἐδόκει προασπίζειν) the opinion that God was the author of evil. Eusebius’ conclusion is accepted by most
ancient and modern writers, but it is suggested by Salmon (Dict. of Christ. Biog. II. 544) that Eusebius was perhaps
mistaken, “for, since the characteristic of dualism is not to make God the author of evil, but to clear him from
the charge by ascribing evil to an independent origin, the title would lead us to think that the letter was directed,
not against one who had himself held God to be the author of evil, but against one who had charged the doctrine
of a single first principle with necessarily leading to this conclusion. And we should have supposed that the object
of Irenæus was to show that it was possible to assert God to be the sole origin and ruler of the universe, without
The Writings of Irenæus against the Schismatics at Rome.
566
The Writings of Irenæus against the Schismatics at Rome.