PHILOSOPHY
whereas he is much less likely to admit that he is always aware
of himself as a necessary condition of the existence of what he
knows. Thus, even if he has no clear recognition of the
difference between the two propositions, he is none the less
haunted by a vague sense of being somehow tricked, when he is
required to take the one as equivalent to the other. Even the
original statement, that subject and object are always known
together, has frequently been challenged. But on this point
I think that Ferrier is right, and that his arguments are sound.
In particular, the following reductio ad absurdum (found p. 88 of
the Institutes) seems to be thoroughly valid. " If it were possible
for an intelligence to receive knowledge at any one time without
knowing that it was his knowledge, it would be possible for him
to do this at all times. So that an intelligent being might be
endowed with knowledge without once, during the whole term
of his existence, knowing that he possessed it." But if this be
absurd, it is equally absurd " to suppose that an intelligence can be
conscious of his knowledge at any single moment, without being
conscious of it as his." On the other hand, the reason which
Ferrier assigns for the fact that the awareness of self is frequently
vague and implicit, is by no means adequate. His explanation is
that " whatever we are extremely intimate with we are very apt
to overlook." " Familiarity breeds neglect." But if this were
the real reason, self-consciousness ought to be more distinct and
emphatic in earlier than in later stages of mental development,
which is contrary to fact.
There is another ambiguity in Ferrier's "primary law or
condition of all knowledge." Taken as it stands on the threshold
of the Institutes, it asserts that subject and object are known
inseparably. What is really meant, as I have pointed out, is
that subject and object are always known as being inseparable.
But this statement also may be interpreted in two ways.
The meaning may be that what is known is apprehended as
161