Demonstrations by Syllogisms.
That God the Word is
Immutable.
1.
We
have confessed one substance of the Father, of the Son, and of the Holy
Ghost, and have agreed that it is immutable. If then there is one
substance of the Trinity, and it is immutable, then the only begotten
Son, who is one person of the Trinity, is immutable. And, if He is
immutable, He was not made flesh by mutation, but is said to have been
made flesh after taking flesh.
2. If God the Word was made
flesh by undergoing mutation into flesh, then He is not immutable. For
no one in his senses would call that which undergoes alteration
immutable. And if He is mutable He is not of one substance with Him
that begat Him. How indeed is it possible for one part of an
uncompounded substance to be mutable and the other immutable? If we
grant this we shall fall headlong into the blasphemy of Arius and
Eunomius, who assert that the Son is of another substance.
3. If the Lord is consubstantial
with the Father, and the Son was made flesh by undergoing change into
flesh, then the substance is at once mutable and immutable, which
blasphemy if any one has the hardihood to maintain, he will no doubt
make it worse by his blasphemy against the Father, for inasmuch as the
Father shares the same substance, he will assuredly call Him
mutable.
4. It is written in the divine
Scriptures that God the Word took flesh, and also a soul. And the most
divine Evangelist says the Word was made flesh.
1575
We must therefore perforce do one of two things: either we must admit
the mutation of the Word into flesh, and reject all divine Scripture,
both Old and New, as teaching lies, or in obedience to the divine
Scripture, we must confess the assumption of the flesh, banishing
mutation from our thoughts, and piously regarding the word of the
Evangelist. This latter we must do inasmuch as we confess the nature of
God the Word to be immutable, and have countless testimonies to the
assumption of the flesh.
5. That which inhabits a
tabernacle is distinct from the tabernacle which is inhabited.
1576
The Evangelist calls the flesh a
tabernacle, and says that God the Word tabernacled therein. “The
Word,” he says, “was made flesh and dwelt among
us.”
1577
Now if He was made flesh by
mutation, He did not dwell in flesh. But we have been taught that He
dwelt in flesh; for the same Evangelist in another place calls His body
a temple.
1578
We must therefore believe the
Evangelist’s explanation and interpretation of what to some
seemed ambiguous.
6. If when the Evangelist wrote
“the Word was made flesh” he had added nothing which could
remove the ambiguity, perhaps the controversy about the passage might
have had some reasonable excuse, from the obscurity of the terms used.
But since he immediately went on to say “and dwelt in us,”
the combatants contend to no purpose. The former clause is explained by
the latter.
7. The immutability of God the
Word is plainly proclaimed by the most wise Evangelist, for after
saying “the Word was made flesh and dwelt among us,” he
immediately adds, “And we beheld His glory, the glory as of the
only-begotten of the Father, full of grace and truth.”
1579
But if, according to the foolish, He had
undergone mutation into flesh, He would not have remained what He was,
but if even when enveloped in the flesh He emitted the rays of His
Father’s nobility, it follows that the nature which He has is
immutable, and it shines even in the body and sends abroad the
brightness of the nature which is unseen. For that light nothing can
dim. “For the light shineth in the darkness, and the darkness
comprehendeth it not,”
1580
as saith the very
divine John.
8. The illustrious Evangelist
was desirous of explaining the glory of the only-begotten, but was
unable to carry out his purpose. He therefore shews it by His
fellowship with the Father. For he says He is of that nature; just as
though any one to persons beholding Joseph sunk in a slavery
inconsistent with his rank, and unaware of the splendour of his
descent, were to point out that Jacob was his father, and his
forefather Abraham. So in this sense the Evangelist said that when He
dwelt among us He did not dim the glory of His nature, “For we
beheld His glory, the
glory as of the only-begotten of the Father.” So if
even when He was made flesh it was plain who He was, then He remained
who he was, and did not undergo the mutation into flesh.
9. We have confessed that God
the Word took not a body only but also a soul. Why then did the divine
Evangelist omit in this place mention of the soul and mention the flesh
alone? Is it not plain that he exhibited the visible nature and by its
means signified the nature united to it? For the mention of the soul is
understood of course in that of the flesh. For when we hear the prophet
saying “Let all flesh bless His holy name,”
1581
we do not understand the prophet to be
exhorting bodies of flesh without souls, but believe the whole to be
summoned to give praise in the summoning of a part.
10. The words “the Word
was made flesh” are plainly indicative not of mutation, but of
His unspeakable loving-kindness. For after the illustrious Evangelist
had said “in the beginning was the Word, and the Word was with
God and the Word was God,” and had declared Him to be Creator of
the visible and invisible, and had called Him life and true light,
adding other similar expressions, and had spoken concerning the Godhead
in such terms as human reason can take in and the language at its
command can express, he went on “And the Word was made
flesh,” as though smitten with amazement and astounded at the
boundless loving-kindness. His existence is eternal; He is God; He made
all things; He is source of eternal life and of true light; and on
account of the salvation of men He put about Him the tabernacle of
flesh. And He was supposed to be only that which He appeared. So for
this reason he did not even mention a soul but only the perishable and
mortal flesh. Of the soul as being immortal he said nothing in order to
exhibit the boundlessness of the kindness.
11. The divine Apostle calls
1582
the Lord Christ seed of Abraham. But if
this is true, as true it is, then God the Word was not changed into
flesh, but took on Him the seed of Abraham, according to the teaching
of the Apostle himself.
12. God swore to David that of
the fruit of his loins, according to the flesh, He would raise up the
Christ, as the prophet
1583
said and as
the great Peter interpreted.
1584
But if God the
Word was called Christ after mutation into flesh, we shall nowhere find
the truth in the oaths. Yet we have been taught that God cannot lie;
nay rather is Himself the truth. Therefore God the Word did not undergo
change into flesh, but in accordance with the promise, took firstfruits
of David’s seed.
1575
John i. 14
1576
σκηνοῦν
and
σκηνούμενον
1577
John i. 14
. The argument
rather requires the rendering “dwelt
in
us,” which
is that of the Rheims Version.
“In nobis qui caro
sumus.”
Bengel. But see Alford
in loc.
1578
John ii. 19
1579
John i. 14
1580
John i. 5
1581
Ps. cxlv. 21
1582
Hebrews ii.
16
1583
Psalm cxxxii.
11
1584
Acts ii. 30