He asserts that we are in error, because, while we do not deny man’s having been created a
rational being by God, we ascribe the invention of words to the logical faculty implanted
by God in man’s nature. And this is the bitterest of his accusations, whereby our teacher of
righteousness is charged with deserting to the tenets of the Atheists, and is denounced as
partaking with and supporting their lawless company, and indeed as guilty of all the most
atrocious offences. Well, then, let this corrector of our blunders tell us, did God give names
to the things which He created? For so says our new interpreter of the mysteries: “Before
the creation of man God named germ, and herb, and grass, and seed, and tree, and the like,
when by the word of His power He brought them severally into being.” If, then, he abides
by the bare letter, and so far Judaizes, and has yet to learn that the Christian is a disciple not
of the letter but of the Spirit (for the letter killeth, says the Apostle, but the Spirit giveth
life1104), and quotes to us the bare literal reading of the words as though God Himself pro-
nounced them—if, I say, he believes this, that, after the similitude of men, God made use
of fluency of speech, expressing His thoughts by voice and accent—if, I repeat, he believes
this, he cannot reasonably deny what follows as its logical consequence. For our speech is
uttered by the organs of speech, the windpipe, the tongue, the teeth, and the mouth, the in-
halation of air from without and the breath from within working together to produce the
utterance. For the windpipe, fitting into the throat like a flute, emits a sound from below;
and the roof of the mouth, by reason of the void space above extending to the nostrils, like
some musical instrument, gives volume from above to the voice. And the cheeks, too, are
aids to speech, contracting and expanding in accordance with their structural arrangement,
or propelling the voice through a narrow passage by various movements of the tongue,
which it effects now with one part of itself now with another, giving hardness or softness to
the sound which passes over it by contact with the teeth or with the palate. Again, the service
of the lips contributes not a little to the result, affecting the voice by the variety of their dis-
tinctive movements, and helping to shape the words as they are uttered.
If, then, God gives things their names as our new expositor of the Divine record assures
us, naming germ, and grass, and tree, and fruit, He must of necessity have pronounced each
of these words not otherwise than as it is pronounced; i.e. according to the composition of
the syllables, some of which are sounded by the lips, others by the tongue, others by both.
But if none of these words could be uttered, except by the operation of vocal organs producing
each syllable and sound by some appropriate movement, he must of necessity ascribe the
possession of such organs to God, and fashion the Divine Being according to the exigencies
of speech. For each adaptation of the vocal organs must be in some form or other, and form
is a bodily limitation. Further, we know very well that all bodies are composite, but where
you see composition you see also dissolution, and dissolution, as the notion implies, is the
1104 2 Cor. iii. 6.
511
Answer to Eunomius' Second Book.