I. One thing that has been complained of is, ministers addressing themselves rather to
the affectionsof their hearers than to their understandings, and striving to raise their passions
to the utmost height, rather by a very affectionate manner of speaking, and a great appearance
391
of earnestness in voice and gesture, than by clear reasoning, and informing their judgment:
by which means it is objected that the affections are moved, without a proportionable en-
lightening of the understanding.
To which I would say, I am far from thinking that it is not very profitable for ministers,
in their preaching, to endeavour clearly and distinctly to explain the doctrines of religion,
and unravel the difficulties that attend them, and to confirm them with strength of reason
and argumentation, and also to observe some easy and clear method in their discourses, for
the help of the understanding and memory; and it is very probable that these things have
been of late too much neglected by many ministers. Yet I believe that the objection made,
of affections raised without enlightening the understanding, is in a great measure built on
a mistake, and confused notions that some have about the nature and cause of the affections,
and the manner in which they depend on the understanding. All affections are raised either
by light in the understanding, or by some error and delusion in the understanding: for all
affections do certainly arise from some apprehension in the understanding; and that appre-
hension must either be agreeable to truth, or else be some mistake or delusion; if it be an
apprehension or notion that is agreeable to truth, then it is light in the understanding.
Therefore the thing to be inquired into is, whether the apprehensions or notions of divine
and eternal things, that are raised in people’s minds by these affectionate preachers, whence
their affections are excited, be apprehensions agreeable to truth, or whether they are mistakes.
If the former, then the affections are raised the way they should be, viz. by informing the
mind, or conveying light to the understanding. They go away with a wrong notion, who
think that those preachers cannot affect their hearers by enlightening their understandings,
except by such a distinct and learned handling of the doctrinal points of religion, as depends
on human discipline, or the strength of natural reason, and tends to enlarge their hearers’
learning, and speculative knowledge in divinity. The manner of preaching without this, may
be such as shall tend very much to set divine and eternal things in a right view, and to give
the hearers such ideas and apprehensions of them as are agreeable to truth, and such impres-
sions on their hearts as are answerable to the real nature of things. And beside the words
that are spoken, the manner of speaking has a great tendency to this. I think an exceeding
affectionate way of preaching about the great things of religion, has in itself no tendency to
beget false apprehensions of them; but on the contrary, a much greater tendency to beget
true apprehensions of them, than a moderate, dull, indifferent way of speaking of them. An
appearance of affection and earnestness in the manner of delivery, though very great indeed,
if it be agreeable to the nature of the subject—and be not beyond a proportion to its import-
ance, and worthiness of affection, and if there be no appearance of its being feigned or
1631
PART III. Wherein the zealous Promoters of this Work have been injuriously…