9. The link of transition lies in the last words of v. 8. The thought of 'the light already shining' naturally suggests the question, Who then is in the light? St John's account of the obligations and issues of love explains this and is an answer to the false claims of knowledge separated from the action which embodies it (comp. v. 4).
Ὁ λέγων...] He that saith. v. 4. It
⁹ μισῶν: + ψεύστης ἐστὶν καὶ ✕ Cypr Lefr.
is always easy to mistake an intellectual knowledge for a spiritual knowledge of the Truth. Real knowledge involves, at least potentially, corresponding action.
ἐν τῷ φωτὶ εἶναι] is in the light, surrounded, as it were, by an atmosphere of divine glory. Comp. i. 7 (iv. 15 note).
μισῶν...] hateth... Indifference is impossible. Comp. Luke xi. 23. There is no twilight in this spiritual world. 'The brother' stands in a relation towards us which makes some feeling on our part inevitable. In such a case there is a simple choice between 'for' and 'against,' that is essentially between 'love' and 'hatred.' 'Hatred' is the expression of a want of sympathy. Where sympathy exists hatred is impossible (John vii. 7); where sympathy does not exist hatred is inevitable (John xv. 18 ff., xvii. 14, iii. 20).
There is however a certain ambiguity in the word 'hate' for it serves as the opposite both to the love of natural affection (φιλεῖν), and to the love of moral judgment (ἀγαπᾶν). In the former case 'hatred,' which may become a moral duty, involves the subjection of an instinct (John xii. 25, xv. 18 f.; comp. Luke xiv. 26); in the latter case 'hatred' expresses a general determination of character (c. iii. 15, iv. 20; comp. Matt. v. 43, vi. 24; Eph. v. 28 f.).
τὸν ἀδελφόν] his brother, that is, his fellow-Christian, and not more generally his fellow-man. It is only through the recognition of the relation to Christ that the wider relation is at last apprehended. The idea of brotherhood under the new dispensation (comp. Acts ii. 37, iii. 17, vi. 3, ix. 30, &c.: Rom. i. 13, &c.) is normally thus limited (yet see Acts xxii. 1, xxviii. 17; Rom. ix. 3). 'Brethren' are those who are united together in Christ to God as their Father (John xx. 17, xxi. 23; comp. Matt. xii. 50). The title occurs significantly in the first record of the action of the Church (Acts i. 15 ἐν μέσῳ τῶν ἀδελφῶν; comp. ix. 30, &c.) and then throughout the apostolic writings (1 Thess v. 26; Gal. i. 2; 1 Cor. v. 11; Rom. xvi. 14 &c.; 1 Tim. vi. 2; James i. 9; 1 Pet. v. 12 &c.; c. iii. 14, 16; 3 John 3, 5, 10.
The singular is characteristic of this epistle (vv. 10, 11, iii. 10, 15, 17, iv. 20 f., v. 16). Comp. Rom. xiv. 10 ff.; 1 Cor. viii. 13. Compare Additional Note on c. iii. 14.
There is, as far as it appears, no case where a fellow-man, as man, is called 'a brother' in the N. T. Such passages as Matt. v. 22 ff., Luke vi. 41 ff., presuppose a special bond of 'brotherhood.' The 'love of the brotherhood' (φιλαδελφία· 1 Thess. iv. 9; Rom. xii. 10; Heb. xiii. 1; 1 Pet. i. 22 (iii. 8); 2 Pet. i. 7) leads up to 'love' (ἀγάπη). But this widest love is expressly assigned in its full extent only to God (John iii. 16, c. iv. 10 f.).
Augustine makes a striking application of the words to the Donatists: Offendit te nescio quis sive malus, sive ut tu putas malus, sive ut tu fingis malus, et deseris tot bonos? Qualis dilectio est fraterna? Qualis apparuit in istis [Donatistis]. Cum accusant Afros deseruerunt orbem terrarum.
And again he points out the ground of the Christian's love of enemies: Sic dilige inimicos ut fratres optes. Sic dilige inimicos ut in societatem tuam vocentur. Sic enim dilexit ille qui in cruce pendens ait Pater ignosce illis, quia nesciunt quid faciunt.
10 ὁ ἀγαπῶν τὸν ἀδελφὸν αὐτοῦ ἐν τῷ φωτὶ μένει, καὶ σκάνδαλον ἐν αὐτῷ οὐκ ἔστιν· 11 ὁ δὲ μισῶν τὸν ἀδελφὸν αὐτοῦ ἐν τῇ σκοτίᾳ ἐστὶν καὶ ἐν τῇ σκοτίᾳ περιπατεῖ,
10 ἐν αὐτῷ οὐκ ἔστιν B vg: οὐκ ἔστιν ἐν αὐτῷ RAC (mc) the.
ἐν τῇ σκ. ἐστίν] is in the darkness. Comp. i. 6 note. The assertion is not simply characterised as false (i. 6 we lie) or as revealing a false nature (v. 4 he is a liar): it involves the existence of a moral state the exact opposite of that which is claimed.
ἴως ἄρτι] usque adhuc V., until now, though the light is actually shining, and he affirms that he is in it, yea even that he has been in it from the first.
Additional Note on ii. 9. St John's view of the state of man.
St John assumes that the actual state of man and of the world is known by experience, from what we see about us and from history and from consciousness.
Naturally 'darkness' (comp. c. i. 5, note) is the sphere in which man abides (John xii. 46; 1 John ii. 9 ἕως ἄρτι) until it is dispelled. (Comp. John viii. 12; 1 Pet. ii. 9; Eph. vi. 12; Col. i. 13.) Under one aspect this darkness has wrought its work, and the crisis is past (c. ii. 11, ἐτύφλωσεν, note). Under another aspect there are times when the darkness falls afresh over men with a thicker gloom (John xii. 35, ἵνα μὴ σκ. ὑ. καταλάβῃ). Viewed from a different point of sight this darkness is death (John v. 24).
¹ E.g. Clem. ad Cor. i. 7 οἱ δὲ (the Ninevites) μετανοήσαντες ἐπὶ τοῖς ἁμαρτήμασιν ἐξιλάσαντο τὸν θεὸν ἱκετεύσαντες. Herm. Vis. i. 2 πῶς ἐξιλάσομαι τὸν θεὸν περὶ τῶν ἁμαρτιῶν μου τῶν τελείων; Test. xii. Patr. Levi 3 οἱ ἄγγελοι...οἱ λειτουργοῦντες καὶ ἐξιλασκόμενοι πρὸς Κύριον ἐπὶ πᾶσαις ταῖς ἀγνοίαις τῶν δικαίων. Philo, de plantat. § 39 (i. 354) εὐξάμενοι καὶ θυσίας ἀναγαγόντες, καὶ ἱλασάμενοι τὸ θεῖον. Comp. Leg. Alleg. iii. § 61 (i. 121 M).
Man by nature in darkness and death.
This state due to external influence.
This present state of man is due to a mysterious interruption of the Divine plan which is noticed abruptly (John i. 5) and came from another order (c. iii. 8). It is not due to a physical or metaphysical necessity, and is foreign to the essence of man. As the creature of God man was made good not absolutely but relatively. Sin has disturbed his normal development (c. iii. 4). Nothing however is said by St John of the Fall; nor does he mention Adam (yet comp. Apoc. xii. 9 ff.; xx. 2 ὁ ὄφις ὁ ἀρχαῖος). The sin of Cain, the manifestation of sin in the realm of human life, and not the sin of Adam, is treated as the archetypal sin (c. iii 12).
Man failed to see God.
As a necessary consequence of his state, man failed of himself to gain a knowledge of God in the way of nature (John i. 10; comp. iii. 3), though he was not left unvisited (John i. 4, 9).
The mission of the Son of God revealed man to himself.
Under these circumstances God sent His Son to save the world, giving in this the measure of His love (John iii. 16 f.; c. iv. 10). But the coming of Christ was in effect a judgment, shewing to men what they had become (John ix. 39; comp. Apoc. iii. 17 ff.; Luke ii. 34 f.). For they were not without the power of recognising this Divine revelation (John xv. 22, 24; v. 36). The will to recognise God and not the capacity was wanting (John v. 40; vii. 17; viii. 44; xii. 48 ἔχει τὸν κρίνοντα; comp. iii. 18; vi. 67; ix. 41). The manifestation of love called out, as a necessary consequence, the opposition of selfishness, hatred (John iii. 19 f.; vii. 7; xv. 18 f., 23 f.; xvii. 14; comp. c. ii. 9, 11; iii. 10, 15; iv. 20). But this hatred was in despite of man's real nature. It is true still that if he violates moral law he 'lies,' and 'deceives himself' (c. i. 6, 8; ii. 4, 22; iv. 20).
The actual state of man shewn in contrasts.
These several traits combine to give a striking view of the grandeur and powerlessness of man ('un roseau pensant'). He is made for God: he is unable of himself to attain to God: God claims his concurrence with the activity of Divine love. And it is most worthy of notice that St John simply declares the antithetic facts in their simple solemnity. He shews no desire to resolve the discords which he accentuates. He leaves them for a state of fuller knowledge and larger life.
Man is in darkness and death (John v. 24; c. iii. 14). On the other side the true Light shineth (John i. 5; xii. 36; c. ii. 8); and Christ offers 'His flesh for the life of the world' (John vi. 51).
The world 'lieth in the Evil One' (c. v. 19). On the other side 'the Prince of the world' is judged and cast out (John xii. 31; xvi. 11; comp. xiii. 40; c. v. 4 ἡ νίκη ἡ νικήσασα). There is a human will which is responsible and therefore in that sense 'free' (John v. 40; iii. 19 ff.; vii. 17). On the other side there is a Divine will which we cannot conceive to be finally ineffective (vi. 44 ff., 65; v. 21).
In the opening of the Gospel, John i. 12 f., these contrasts find a concurrent affirmation. On the one side the human element is seen in ἔλαβον, πιστεύονσιν, γενέσθαι. On the other side the Divine element is seen in ἐγεννήθησαν, ἔδωκεν ἐξουσίαν, τέκνα θεοῦ. Comp. John vi. 27 ff. (ἐργάζεσθε, δώσει).
The wide extent of these contrasts.
The same clear assertion of truths which appear to be in opposition extends to other parts of the region of Divine and human relations. There is one absolute message (John xii. 48); and yet concessions are made that men may embrace it more readily (John v. 34; comp. viii. 17). There is a group whom Christ speaks of as His own (John x. 27, 4); and yet He appeals generally to all, for the image of thirst expresses a universal want which Christ alone can satisfy (John vii. 37). A new birth is necessary for the perception of the Divine Kingdom and entrance into it (John iii. 3 ff.); and yet there are, as still without it, those who 'are of the truth' (John xviii. 37), who 'do the truth' (iii. 21), who are 'children of God' (xi. 52).
In part we can see perhaps where the reconciliation of these statements can be found. In part they finally go back to the fundamental antithesis of the finite and infinite before which our present powers fail. The teaching of St John helps us to see that it is enough that we hold the fulness of the truth as it is presented to us in complementary fragments.
{"canonical_mapping_status":"native_coordinates_only; no canonical mapping inferred","footnote_boundary_status":"whole_native_row_preserved; no independent-note segmentation or note-count claim","html_tags":{"b":6,"p":35},"id":"sqlite3:280aa5b578b17d3dd9b56ec9d0f065a1b154f8e7c2e467799a3faacf064f545f:commentaries:20","native_body_column":"text","native_module_metadata":{"$context_sha256":"c696c188a5bc382915c66fa78834b5c544a6f2c23fc77ed893080f26b218c382"},"native_reference":{"book_number":690,"chapter_number_from":2,"chapter_number_to":2,"verse_number_from":9,"verse_number_to":9},"native_rowid":20,"native_table":"commentaries","projection":"HTML character data with explicit block newlines; no text-node deletion or whitespace folding; original HTML retained","public_import_allowed":false,"record_kind":"native-verse-keyed-module-record","semantic_kind_reviewed":false,"source_family_classification":"sermonindex","source_html":{"$text_sha256":"37b2a48dad1fc8a3f8336c3908490bd0e4097d41a3036eccb98608e77a3fb42f"},"source_html_sha256":"37b2a48dad1fc8a3f8336c3908490bd0e4097d41a3036eccb98608e77a3fb42f","source_locator":{"$context_sha256":"2a8c06bf10237edc9987935a6bf5ce2f9c1b3d30a1a066b4a90d1c5c99739cf5"},"source_origin_path":"SI-WESTCOTT.commentaries.SQLite3","source_sha256":"280aa5b578b17d3dd9b56ec9d0f065a1b154f8e7c2e467799a3faacf064f545f"}