own—advised, in the one case, the whole church to withdraw from the minister; and in the
other, a minority to separate themselves from the majority, and to form a distinct church
and congregation. This indiscreet advice had, at times, too much influence, and occasioned
in some places the sundering of churches and congregations, in others the removal of min-
isters, and in others the separation of individuals from the communion of their brethren.
It thus introduced contentions and quarrels into churches and families, alienated ministers
from each other, and from their people, and produced, in the places where these consequences
were most discernible, a wide-spread and riveted prejudice against revivals of religion. It is
deserving perhaps of inquiry, Whether the subsequent slumber of the American church,
for nearly seventy years, may not be ascribed, in an important degree, to the fatal re-action
of these unhappy measures.
There can be no doubt that on Mr. Whitefield (although by his multiplied and successful
labours he was the means of incalculable good to the churches of America, as well as to
those of England and Scotland) these evils are, to a considerable degree, to be charged, as
having first led the way in this career of irregularity and disorder. He did not go as far as
some of his followers; but he opened a wide door, and went great lengths, in these forbidden
paths; and his imitators, having less discretion and experience, ventured, under the cover
of his example, even beyond the limits which he himself was afraid to pass. His published
journals show, that he was accustomed to decide too authoritatively, whether others, partic-
ularly ministers, were converted; as well as to insist that churches ought to remove those,
whom they regarded as unconverted ministers; and that individual Christians or minorities
of churches, where a majority refused to do this, were bound to separate themselves. Mr.
Edwards, wholly disapproving of this conduct, conversed with Mr. Whitefield freely, in the
presence of others, about his practice of pronouncing ministers, and other members of the
christian church, unconverted; and declares that he supposed him to be of the opinion, that
unconverted ministers ought not to be continued in the ministry; and that he supposed that
he endeavoured to propagate this opinion, and a practice agreeable thereto. The same may
be said, in substance, of Mr. G. Tennent, Mr. Finley, and Mr. Davenport, all of whom became
early convinced of their error, and with christian sincerity openly acknowledged it. At the
same time, while these things were to be regretted in themselves, and still more so in their
unhappy consequences, the evidence is clear that, in far the greater number of places, these
irregularities and disorders, if in any degree prevalent, were never predominant; and that
the attention to religion in these places, while it continued, was most obviously a great and
powerful work of the Spirit of God. The testimony of the ministers of those places, on these
points, is explicit. It is given with great caution, and with the utmost candour; it acknowledges
frankly the evils then experienced; and it details the actual moral change wrought in indi-
viduals and in society at large, in such a manner, that no one, who believes in regeneration
as the work of the Holy Spirit, can doubt that this change was effected by the finger of God.
139
CHAPTER XII. Extent of the revival of 1740-1742. Auspicious opening. Opposed…