Chapter 1.—1. We have the testimony of the blessed Cyprian, that the custom of the
Catholic Church is at present retained, when men coming from the side of heretics or
schismatics, if they have received baptism as consecrated in the words of the gospel, are not
baptized afresh. For he himself proposed to himself the question, and that as coming from
the mouth of brethren either seeking the truth or contending for the truth. For in the course
of the arguments by which he wished to show that heretics should be baptized again, which
we have sufficiently considered for our present purpose in the former books, he says: "But
some will say, What then will become of those who in times past, coming to the Church
from heresy, were admitted without baptism?"1469 In this question is involved the shipwreck
of the whole cause of the Donatists, with whom our contest is on this point. For if those
had not really baptism who were thus received on coming from heretics, and their sins were
still upon them, then, when such men were admitted to communion, either by those who
came before Cyprian or by Cyprian himself, we must acknowledge that one of two things
occurred,—either that the Church perished then and there from the pollution of communion
with such men, or that any one abiding in unity is not injured by even the notorious sins of
other men. But since they cannot say that the Church then perished through the contamin-
ation arising from communion with those who, as Cyprian says, were admitted into it
without baptism—for otherwise they cannot maintain the validity of their own origin if the
Church then perished, seeing that the list of consuls proves that more than forty years elapsed
between the martyrdom of Cyprian and the burning of the sacred books,1470 from which
they took occasion to make a schism, spreading abroad the smoke of their calumnies,—it
therefore is left for them to acknowledge that the unity of Christ is not polluted by any such
communion, even with known offenders. And, after this confession, they will be unable to
discover any reason which will justify them in maintaining that they were bound to separate
from the churches of the whole world, which, as we read, were equally founded by the
apostles, seeing that, while the others could not have perished from any admixture of offend-
ers, of whatsoever kind, they, though they would not have perished if they had remained in
unity with them, brought destruction on themselves in schism, by separating themselves
from their brethren, and breaking the bond of peace. For the sacrilege of schism is most
clearly evident in them, if they had no sufficient cause for separation. And it is clear that
there was no sufficient cause for separation, if even the presence of notorious offenders
cannot pollute the good while they abide in unity. But that the good, abiding in unity, are
not polluted even by notorious offenders, we teach on the testimony of Cyprian, who says
that "men in past times, coming to the Church from heresy, were admitted without baptism;"
and yet, if the wickedness of their sacrilege, which was still upon them, seeing it had not
1469 Cypr. Ep. lxxiii. ad Jubaian. 23.
1470 See below, Book VII. c. 2, 3.
Chapter 1
824
Chapter 1