Chapter 2.—3. Whence, then, is a man to be cleansed who receives baptism, when the
conscience of the giver is polluted without the knowledge of him who is to receive it? Espe-
cially when he goes on to say, "For he who receives faith from the faithless receives not faith,
but guilt." There stands before us one that is faithless ready to baptize, and he who should
be baptized is ignorant of his faithlessness: what think you that he will receive? Faith, or
guilt? If you answer faith, then you will grant that it is possible that a man should receive
not guilt, but faith, from him that is faithless; and the former saying will be false, that "he
who receives faith from the faithless receives not faith, but guilt." For we find that it is pos-
sible that a man should receive faith even from one that is faithless, if he be not aware of the
faithlessness of the giver. For he does not say, He who receives faith from one that is openly
and notoriously faithless; but he says, "He who receives faith from the faithless receives not
faith, but guilt;" which certainly is false when a person is baptized by one who hides his
faithlessness. But if he shall say, Even when the faithlessness of the baptizer is concealed,
the recipient receives not faith from him, but guilt, then let them rebaptize those who are
well known to have been baptized by men who in their own body have long concealed a life
of guilt, but have eventually been detected, convicted, and condemned.
Chapter 2
983
Chapter 2