Technische verwerking bevestigt geen inhoudelijke beoordeling of toestemming voor openbare publicatie.
Versie 84b8f9d0000f64f7b9617294eafa82492a4f07f60c1ac59c9d5187b8fa966114
{"author":null,"canonical_references":[],"database_sha256":"8cfbe7284c6936871d57c02dc6aa63ebbdfd4722422d539dd9f716e46e91112e","date_end":null,"date_start":null,"edition_year":null,"id":"sermonindex-ecf-9253","native_reference":{"book_number":500,"chapter_from":2,"chapter_to":2,"system":"MyBible module coordinates (mapping unverified)","verse_from":4,"verse_to":4},"public_import_allowed":false,"record_kind":"verse-keyed-module-record","review_required":["English edition and exact text","author/work attribution","dating","verse mapping and citation kind","reuse and attribution","split author quotations and deduplicate"],"review_status":"unreviewed","source_html":"<p><b>Ammonius of Alexandria</b>: He chides his mother for having importunely reminded God, who has no need to be reminded of anything. It is as if he had said, \"Do not regard me only as a man but also as God. Not yet has the time of my manifestation come. Not as yet is it known who I am.\"<br/><i>— FRAGMENTS ON John 57</i></p><p><b>Augustine of Hippo</b>: It is because of an indubitable mystery that He appears not to acknowledge His mother, from whom as the Bridegroom He came forth, when He says to her, \"Woman, what have I to do with thee? Mine hour is not yet come.\" What is this? Did He come to the marriage for the purpose of teaching men to treat their mothers with contempt? Surely he to whose marriage He had come was taking a wife with the view of having children, and surely he wished to be honored by those children he would beget: had Jesus then come to the marriage in order to dishonor His mother, when marriages are celebrated and wives married with the view of having children, whom God commands to honor their parents? Beyond all doubt, brethren, there is some mystery lurking here.<br/><i>— Tractates on John 8</i></p><p><b>Augustine of Hippo</b>: It is really a matter of such importance that some,-of whom the apostle, as we have mentioned before, has forewarned us to be on our guard, saying, \"I fear, lest, as the serpent beguiled Eve by his subtilty, so also your minds should be corrupted from the simplicity and chastity which is in Christ,\"-taking away from the credibility of the gospel, and asserting that Jesus was not born of the Virgin Mary, used to endeavor to draw from this place an argument in support of their error, so far as to say, How could she be His mother, to whom He said, \"Woman, what have I to do with thee?\" Wherefore we must answer them, and show them why the Lord said this, lest in their insanity they appear to themselves to have discovered something contrary to wholesome belief, whereby the chastity of the virgin bride may be corrupted, that is, whereby the faith of the Church may be injured. For in very deed, brethren, their faith is corrupted who prefer a lie to the truth. For these men, who appear to honor Christ in such wise as to deny that He had flesh, do nothing short of proclaiming Him a liar. Now they who build up a lie in men, what do they but drive the truth out of them? They let in the devil, they drive Christ out; they let in an adulterer, shut out the bridegroom, being evidently paranymphs, or rather, the panderers of the serpent. For it is for this object they speak, that the serpent may possess, and Christ be shut out.<br/><i>— Tractates on John 8</i></p><p><b>Augustine of Hippo</b>: How doth the serpent possess? When a lie possesses. When falsehood possesses, then the serpent possesses; when truth possesses, then Christ possesses. For Himself has said, \"I am the truth;\" but of that other He said, \"He stood not in the truth, because the truth is not him.\" And Christ is the truth in such wise that thou shouldst receive the whole to be true in Him. The true Word, God equal with the Father, true soul, true flesh, true man, true God, true nativity, true passion, true death, true resurrection. If thou say that any of these is false, rottenness enters, the worms of falsehood are bred of the poison of the serpent, and nothing sound will remain.<br/><i>— Tractates on John 8</i></p><p><b>Augustine of Hippo</b>: Why, then, said the Son to the mother, \"Woman, what have I to do with thee? mine hour is not yet come?\" Our Lord Jesus Christ was both God and man. According as He was God, He had not a mother; according as He was man, He had. She was the mother, then, of His flesh, of His humanity, of the weakness which for our sakes He took upon Him. But the miracle which He was about to do, He was about to do according to His divine nature, not according to His weakness; according to that wherein He was God not according to that wherein He was born weak. But the weakness of God is stronger than men. His mother then demanded a miracle of Him; but He, about to perform divine works, so far did not recognize a human womb; saying in effect, \"That in me which works a miracle was not born of thee, thou gavest not birth to my divine nature; but because my weakness was born of thee, I will recognize thee at the time when that same weakness shall hang upon the cross.\" This, indeed, is the meaning of \"Mine hour is not yet come.\" For then it was that He recognized, who, in truth, always did know. He knew His mother in predestination, even before He was born of her; even before, as God, He created her of whom, as man, He was to be created, He knew her as His mother: but at a certain hour in a mystery He did not recognize her; and at a certain hour which had not yet come, again in a mystery, He does recognize her. For then did He recognize her, when that to which she gave birth was a-dying. That by which Mary was made did not die, but that which was made of Mary; not the eternity of the divine nature, but the weakness of the flesh, was dying. He made that answer therefore, making a distinction in the faith of believers, between the who; and the how, He came.<br/><i>— Tractates on John 8</i></p><p><b>Augustine of Hippo</b>: For while He was God and the Lord of heaven and earth, He came by a mother who was a woman. In that He was Lord of the world, Lord of heaven and earth, He was, of course, the Lord of Mary also; but in that wherein it is said, \"Made of a woman, made under the law,\" He was Mary's son. The same both the Lord of Mary and the son of Mary; the same both the Creator of Mary and created from Mary. Marvel not that He was both son and Lord. For just as He is called the son of Mary, so likewise is He called the son of David; and son of David because son of Mary. Hear the apostle openly declaring, \"Who was made of the seed of David according to the flesh.\" Hear Him also declared the Lord of David; let David himself declare this: \"The Lord said to my Lord, Sit Thou on my right hand.\" And this passage Jesus Himself brought forward to the Jews, and refuted them from it. How then was He both David's son and David's Lord? David's son according to the flesh, David's Lord according to His divinity; so also Mary's son after the flesh, and Mary's Lord after His majesty.<br/><i>— Tractates on John 8</i></p><p><b>Augustine of Hippo</b>: Now as she was not the mother of His divine nature, whilst it was by His divinity the miracle she asked for would be wrought, therefore He answered her, \"Woman, what have I to do with thee?\" But think not that I deny thee to be my mother: \"Mine hour is not yet come;\" for in that hour I will acknowledge thee, when the weakness of which thou art the mother comes to hang on the cross. Let us prove the truth of this. When the Lord suffered, the same evangelist tells us, who knew the mother of the Lord, and who has given us to know about her in this marriage feast,-the same, I say, tells us, \"There was there near the cross the mother of Jesus; and Jesus saith to His mother, Woman, behold thy son! and to the disciple, Behold thy mother!\" He commends His mother to the care of the disciple; commends His mother, as about to die before her, and to rise again before her death. The man commends her a human being to man's care. This humanity had Mary given birth to. That hour had now come, the hour of which He had then said, \"Mine hour is not yet come.\"<br/><i>— Tractates on John 8</i></p><p><b>Augustine of Hippo</b>: Now then, if it seem good, brethren, those men being repulsed, and ever wandering in their own blindness, unless in humility they be healed, let us inquire why our Lord answered His mother in such a manner. He was in an extraordinary manner begotten of the Father without a mother, born of a mother without a father; without a mother He was God, without a father He was man; without a mother before all time, without a father in the end of times. What He said was said in answer to His mother, for \"the mother of Jesus was there,\" and \"His mother said unto Him.\" All this the Gospel says. It is there we learn that \"the mother of Jesus was there,\" just where we learn that He said unto her, \"Woman, what have I to do with thee? mine hour is not yet come.\" Let us believe the whole; and what we do not yet understand, let us search out. And first take care, lest perhaps, as the Manicaeans found occasion for their falsehood, because the Lord said, \"Woman, what have I to do with thee?\" the astrologers in like manner may find occasion for their deception, in that He said, \"Mine hour is not yet come.\"<br/><i>— Tractates on John 8</i></p><p><b>Augustine of Hippo</b>: If it was in the sense of the astrologers He said this, we have committed a sacrilege in burning their books. But if we have acted rightly, as was done in the times of the apostles, it was not according to their notion that the Lord said, \"Mine hour is not yet come.\" For, say those vain-talkers and deceived seducers, thou seest that Christ was under fate, as He says, \"Mine hour is not yet come.\" To whom then must we make answer first-to the heretics or to the astrologers? For both come of the serpent, and desire to corrupt the Church's virginity of heart, which she holds in undefiled faith.<br/><i>— Tractates on John 8</i></p><p><b>Augustine of Hippo</b>: Now then, brethren, we have answered the heretics. Let us now answer the astrologers. And how do they attempt to prove that Jesus was under fate? Because, say they, Himself said, \"Mine hour is not yet come.\" Therefore we believe Him; and if He had said, \"I have no hour,\" He would have excluded the astrologers: but behold, say they, He said, \"Mine hour is not yet come.\" If then He had said, \"I have no hour,\" the astrologers would have been shut out, and would have no ground for their slander; but now that He said, \"Mine hour is not yet come,\" how can we contradict His own words? 'Tis wonderful that the astrologers, by believing Christ's words, endeavor to convince Christians that Christ lived under an hour of fate. Well, let them believe Christ when He saith, \"I have power to lay down my life and to take it up again: no man taketh it from me, but I lay it down of myself, and I take it again.\" Is this power then under fate? Let them show us a man who has it in his power when to die, how long to live: this they can never do. Let them, therefore, believe God when He says, \"I have power to lay down my life, and to take it up again;\" and let them inquire why it was said, \"Mine hour is not yet come;\" and let them not because of these words, be imposing fate on the Maker of heaven, the Creator and Ruler of the stars. For even if fate were from the stars, the Maker of the stars could not be subject to their destiny. Moreover, not only Christ had not what thou callest fate, but not even hast thou, or I, or he there, or any human being whatsoever.<br/><i>— Tractates on John 8</i></p><p><b>Augustine of Hippo</b>: Why then did He say, \"Mine hour is not yet come?\" Rather because, having it in His power when to die, He did not yet see it fit to use that power. Just as we, brethren, say, for example, \"Now is the appointed hour for us to go out to celebrate the sacraments.\" If we go out before it is necessary, do we not act perversely and absurdly? And because we act only at the proper time, do we therefore in this action regard fate when we so express ourselves? What means then, \"Mine hour is not yet come?\" When I know that it is the fitting time for me to suffer, when my suffering will be profitable, then I will willingly suffer. That hour is not yet: that thou mayest preserve both, this, \"Mine hour is not yet come;\" and that, \"I have power to lay down my life, and power to take it again.\" He had come, then, having it in His power when to die. And surely it would not have been right were He to die before He had chosen disciples. Had he been a man who had not his hour in his own power, he might have died before he had chosen disciples; and if haply he had died when his disciples were now chosen and instructed, it would be something conferred on him, not his own doing. But, on the contrary, He who had come having in His power when to go, when to return, how far to advance, and for whom the regions of the grave were open, not only when dying but when rising again; He, I say, in order to show us His Church's hope of immortality, showed in the head what it behoved the members to expect.<br/><i>— Tractates on John 8</i></p><p><b>Augustine of Hippo</b>: The hour then had not yet come, the fit time was not yet. Disciples had to be called, the kingdom of heaven to be proclaimed, the Lord's divinity to be shown forth in miracles, and His humanity in His very sympathy with mortal men. For He who hungered because He was man, fed so many thousands with five loaves because He was God; He who slept because He was man, commanded the winds and the waves because He was God. All these things had first to be set forth, that the evangelists might have whereof to write, that there might be what should be preached to the Church. But when He had done as much as He judged to be sufficient, then His hour came, not of necessity, but of will,-not of condition, but of power.<br/><i>— Tractates on John 8</i></p><p><b>Augustine of Hippo</b>: And there, although the evangelist himself mentions His mother by that very name, He nevertheless addresses her thus: \"Woman, what have I to do with thee?\" In this, however, it is to be understood that He does not repel her of whom He received the flesh, but means to convey the conception of His divinity with special fitness at this time, when He is about to change the water into wine; which divinity, likewise, had made that woman, and had not itself been made in her.<br/><i>— The Harmony of the Gospels, Book 4</i></p><p><b>Augustine of Hippo</b>: Neither is there anything to compel us to a denial of the mother of the Lord, in the circumstance that this word was spoken by Him: \"Woman, what have I to do with thee? Mine hour is not yet come.\" But He rather admonishes us to understand that, in respect of His being God, there was no mother for Him, the part of whose personal majesty He was preparing to show forth in the turning of water into wine. But as regards His being crucified, He was crucified in respect of his being man; and that was the hour which had not come as yet, at the time when this word was spoken, \"What have I to do with thee? Mine hour is not yet come;\" that is, the hour at which I shall recognize thee. For at that period, when He was crucified as man, He recognized His human mother, and committed her most humanely to the care of the best beloved disciple.<br/><i>— A Treatise on Faith and the Creed</i></p><p><b>Augustine of Hippo ((as quoted by Aquinas, AD 1274))</b>: (Tr. viii. c. 5) Some who derogate from the Gospel, and say that Jesus was not born of the Virgin Mary, try to draw an argument for their error from this place; for, how, say they, could she be His mother to whom He said, What have I to do with thee? Now who is it who gives this account, and on whose authority do we believe it? The Evangelist John. But he himself says, The mother of Jesus was there. Why should He say it, unless both were true. But did He therefore come to the marriage to teach men to despise their mother?</p><p>(de Symbolo Serm. ii. c. 14. [5]) To mark a distinction between His Godhead and manhood, that according to His manhood He was inferior and subject, but according to His Godhead supreme, He saith, Woman, what have I to do with thee?</p><p>(Tr. viii. c. 9. et seq. sparsim) Or it was because our Lord as God had not a mother, though as man He had, and the miracle He was about to work was the act of His Divinity, not of human infirmity. When therefore His mother demanded a miracle, He, as though not acknowledging a human birth, when about to perform a divine work, said, Woman, what have I to do with thee? As if He said, Thou didst not beget that in Me, which works the miracle, My Divinity. (She is called woman, with reference to the female sex, not to any injury of her virginity.) But because thou broughtest forth My infirmity, I will acknowledge thee then, when that very infirmity shall hang on the cross. And therefore He adds, Mine hour is not yet come: as if to say, I will acknowledge thee when the infirmity, of which thou art the mother, shall hang from the cross. He commended His mother to the disciple, when about to die, and to rise again, before her death. But note; just as the Manicheans have found an occasion of error and pretext for their faithlessness in our Lord's word, What have I to do with thee? in the same way the astrologers support theirs from the words, Mine hour is not yet come. For, say they, if Christ had not been under the power of fate, He would never have said this. But let them believe what God says below, I have power to lay it (my life) down, and I have power to take it again: (John 10:18) and then let them ask, why He says, Mine hour is not yet come: nor let them on such a ground subject the Creator of heaven to fate; seeing that, even were there a fatality in the stars, the Maker of the stars could not be under the dominion of the stars. And not only had Christ nothing to do with fate, as ye call it; but neither hast thou, or any other man. Wherefore said He then, Mine hour is not yet come? Because He had the power to die when He pleased, but did not think it expedient yet to exert the power. He was to call the disciples, to proclaim the Kingdom of heaven, to do marvellous works, to approve His divinity by miracles, His humility by partaking of the sufferings of our mortal state. And when He had done all, then the hour was come, not of destiny, but of will, not of obligation, but of power.<br/><i>— Catena Aurea by Aquinas</i></p><p><b>Augustine of Hippo</b>: I ask you, O faithful Christians, Was the mother of Jesus there? Answer ye, She was. Whence know you? Answer, The Gospel says it. What answer made Jesus to His mother? Answer ye, \"Woman, what have I to do with thee? mine hour is not yet come.\" And whence know you this? Answer, The Gospel says it. Let no man corrupt this your faith, if you desire to preserve a chaste virginity for the Bridegroom. But if it be asked of you, why He made this answer to His mother, let him declare who understands; but he who does not as yet understand, let him most firmly believe that Jesus made this answer, and made it moreover to His mother. By this piety he will learn to understand also why Jesus answered thus, if by praying he knock at the door of truth, and do not approach it with wrangling. Only this much, while he fancies himself to know, or is ashamed because he does not know, why Jesus answered thus, let him beware lest he be constrained to believe either that the evangelist lied when he said, \"The mother of Jesus was there,\" or that Jesus Himself suffered for our sins by a counterfeit death and for our justification showed counterfeit scars; and that He spoke falsely in saying, \"If ye continue in my word, ye are my disciples indeed; and ye shall know the truth, and the truth shall make you free.\" For if He had a false mother, false flesh, false death, false wounds in His death, false scars in His resurrection, then it will not be the truth, but rather falsehood, that shall make free those that believe on Him.<br/><i>— Tractates on John 8</i></p><p><b>Cyril of Alexandria</b>: Most excellently did the Saviour fashion for us this discourse also. For it behoved Him not to come hastily to action, nor to appear a Worker of miracles as though of His Own accord, but, being called, hardly to come thereto, and to grant the grace to the necessity rather than to the lookers on. But the issue of things longed for seems somehow to be even more grateful, when granted not off-hand to those who ask for it, but through a little delay put forth to most lovely hope. Besides, Christ hereby shows that the deepest honour is due to parents, admitting out of reverence to His Mother what He willed not as yet to do.<br/><i>— Commentary on the Gospel of John, Book 2</i></p><p><b>Hippolytus of Rome</b>: When, therefore, he says, the entire Sonship shall have come, and shall be above the conterminous spirit, then the creature will become the object of mercy. For (the creature) groans until now, and is tormented, and waits for the manifestation of the sons of God, in order that all who are men of the Sonship may ascend from thence. When this takes place, God, he says, will bring upon the whole world enormous ignorance, that all things may continue according to nature, and that nothing may inordinately desire anything of the things that are contrary to nature. But (far from it); for all the souls of this quarter of creation, as many as possess the nature of remaining immortal in this (region) only, continue (in it), aware of nothing superior or better (than their present state). And there will not prevail any rumour or knowledge in regions below, concerning beings whose dwelling is placed above, lest subjacent souls should be wrung with torture from longing after impossibilities. (It would be) just as if a fish were to crave to feed on the mountains along with sheep. (For) a wish of this description would, he says, be their destruction. All things, therefore, that abide in (this) quarter are incorruptible, but corruptible if they are disposed to wander and cross over from the things that are according to nature. In this way the Archon of the Hebdomad will know nothing of superjacent entities. For enormous ignorance will lay hold on this one likewise, in order that sorrow, and grief, and groaning may depart from him; for he will not desire aught of impossible things, nor will he be visited with anguish. In like manner, however, the same ignorance will lay hold also on the Great Archon of the Ogdoad, and similarly on all the creatures that are subject unto him, in order that in no respect anything may desire aught of those things that are contrary to nature, and may not (thus) be overwhelmed with sorrow. And so there will be the restitution of all things which, in conformity with nature, have from the beginning a foundation in the seed of the universe, but will be restored at (their own) proper periods. And that each thing, says (Basilides), has its own particular times, the Saviour is a sufficient (witness ) when He observes, \"Mine hour is not yet come.\" And the Magi (afford similar testimony) when they gaze wistfully upon the (Saviour's) star. For (Jesus) Himself was, he says, mentally preconceived at the time of the generation of the stars, and of the complete return to their starting-point of the seasons in the vast conglomeration (of all germs). This is, according to these (Basilidians), he who has been conceived as the inner spiritual man in what is natural (now this is the Sonship which left there the soul, not (that it might be) mortal, but that it might abide here according to nature, just as the first Sonship left above in its proper locality the Holy Spirit, (that is, the spirit) which is conterminous),-(this, I say, is he who has been conceived as the inner spiritual man, and) has then been arrayed in his own peculiar soul.<br/><i>— Hippolytus Refutation of All Heresies Book VII</i></p><p><b>Irenaeus</b>: With Him is nothing incomplete or out of due season, just as with the Father there is nothing incongruous. For all these things were foreknown by the Father; but the Son works them out at the proper time in perfect order and sequence. This was the reason why, when Mary was urging [Him] on to [perform] the wonderful miracle of the wine, and was desirous before the time to partake of the cup of emblematic significance, the Lord, checking her untimely haste, said, \"Woman, what have I to do with thee? mine hour is not yet come\"—waiting for that hour which was foreknown by the Father. This is also the reason why, when men were often desirous to take Him, it is said, \"No man laid hands upon Him, for the hour of His being taken was not yet come;\" nor the time of His passion, which had been foreknown by the Father; as also says the prophet Habakkuk, \"By this Thou shalt be known when the years have drawn nigh; Thou shalt be set forth when the time comes; because my soul is disturbed by anger, Thou shalt remember Thy mercy.\" Paul also says: \"But when the fulness of time came, God sent forth His Son.\" By which is made manifest, that all things which had been foreknown of the Father, our Lord did accomplish in their order, season, and hour, foreknown and fitting, being indeed one and the same, but rich and great. For He fulfils the bountiful and comprehensive will of His Father, inasmuch as He is Himself the Saviour of those who are saved, and the Lord of those who are under authority, and the God of all those things which have been formed, the only-begotten of the Father, Christ who was announced, and the Word of God, who became incarnate when the fulness of time had come, at which the Son of God had to become the Son of man.<br/><i>— Against Heresies Book III, Chapter XVI</i></p><p><b>John Chrysostom</b>: The words are not used in this place only, but in others also; for the same Evangelist says, \"They could not lay hands on Him, because His hour was not yet come\" (c. viii. 20); and again, \"No man laid hands on Him, because His hour was not yet come\" (c. vii. 30); and again, \"The hour is come, glorify Thy Son.\" (c. xvii. 1.) What then do the words mean? I have brought together more instances, that I may give one explanation of all. And what is that explanation? Christ did not say, \"Mine hour is not yet come,\" as being subject to the necessity of seasons, or the observance of an \"hour\"; how can He be so, who is Maker of seasons, and Creator of the times and the ages? To what else then did He allude? He desires to show this; that He works all things at their convenient season, not doing all at once; because a kind of confusion and disorder would have ensued, if, instead of working all at their proper seasons, He had mixed all together, His Birth, His Resurrection, and His coming to Judgment. Observe this; creation was to be, yet not all at once; man and woman were to be created, yet not even these together; mankind were to be condemned to death, and there was to be a resurrection, yet the interval between the two was to be great; the law was to be given, but not grace with it, each was to be dispensed at its proper time. Now Christ was not subject to the necessity of seasons, but rather settled their order, since He is their Creator; and therefore He saith in this place, \"Mine hour is not yet come.\"<br/><i>— Homily on the Gospel of John 22</i></p><p><b>John Chrysostom</b>: And His meaning is, that as yet He was not manifest to the many, nor had He even His whole company of disciples; Andrew followed Him, and next to him Philip, but no one else. And moreover, none of these, not even His mother nor His brethren, knew Him as they ought; for after His many miracles, the Evangelist says of His brethren, \"For neither did His brethren believe in Him.\" (c. vii. 5.) And those at the wedding did not know Him either, for in their need they would certainly have come to and entreated Him. Therefore He saith, \"Mine hour is not yet come\"; that is, \"I am not yet known to the company, nor are they even aware that the wine has failed; let them first be sensible of this. I ought not to have been told it from thee; thou art My mother, and renderest the miracle suspicious. They who wanted the wine should have come and besought Me, not that I need this, but that they might with an entire assent accept the miracle. For one who knows that he is in need, is very grateful when he obtains assistance; but one who has not a sense of his need, will never have a plain and clear sense of the benefit.\"<br/><i>— Homily on the Gospel of John 22</i></p><p><b>John Chrysostom</b>: Why then after He had said, \"Mine hour is not yet come,\" and given her a denial, did He what His mother desired? Chiefly it was, that they who opposed Him, and thought that He was subject to the \"hour,\" might have sufficient proof that He was subject to no hour; for had He been so, how could He, before the proper \"hour\" was come, have done what He did? And in the next place, He did it to honor His mother, that He might not seem entirely to contradict and shame her that bare Him in the presence of so many; and also, that He might not be thought to want power, for she brought the servants to Him.<br/><i>— Homily on the Gospel of John 22</i></p><p><b>John Chrysostom</b>: \"How then,\" asks some one, \"came it into the mind of His mother to imagine anything great of Him?\" He was now beginning to reveal Himself, and was plainly discovered by the witness of John, and by what He had said to His disciples. And before all this, the Conception itself and all its attending circumstances had inspired her with a very great opinion of the Child; \"for,\" said Luke, \"she heard all the sayings concerning the Child, and kept them in her heart.\" \"Why then,\" says one, \"did not she speak this before?\" Because, as I said, it was now at last that He was beginning to manifest Himself. Before this time He lived as one of the many, and therefore His mother had not confidence to say any such thing to Him; but when she heard that John had come on His account, and that he had borne such witness to Him as he did, and that He had disciples, after that she took confidence, and called Him, and said, when they wanted wine, \"They have no wine.\" For she desired both to do them a favor, and through her Son to render herself more conspicuous; perhaps too she had some human feelings, like His brethren, when they said, \"Show thyself to the world\" (c. xvii. 4), desiring to gain credit from His miracles. Therefore He answered somewhat vehemently, saying, \"Woman, what have I to do with thee? Mine hour is not yet come.\"<br/><i>— Homily on the Gospel of John 21</i></p><p><b>John Chrysostom</b>: To prove that He greatly respected His mother, hear Luke relate how He was \"subject to\" His parents (Luke ii. 51), and our own Evangelist declare how He had forethought for her at the very season of the Crucifixion. For where parents cause no impediment or hindrance in things belonging to God, it is our bounden duty to give way to them, and there is great danger in not doing so; but when they require anything unseasonably, and cause hindrance in any spiritual matter, it is unsafe to obey. And therefore He answered thus in this place, and again elsewhere, \"Who is My mother, and who are My brethren?\" (Matt. xii. 48), because they did not yet think rightly of Him; and she, because she had borne Him, claimed, according to the custom of other mothers, to direct Him in all things, when she ought to have reverenced and worshiped Him. This then was the reason why He answered as He did on that occasion. For consider what a thing it was, that when all the people high and low were standing round Him, when the multitude was intent on hearing Him, and His doctrine had begun to be set forth, she should come into the midst and take Him away from the work of exhortation, and converse with Him apart, and not even endure to come within, but draw Him outside merely to herself. This is why He said, \"Who is My mother and My brethren?\" Not to insult her who had borne Him, (away with the thought!) but to procure her the greatest benefit, and not to let her think meanly of Him. For if He cared for others, and used every means to implant in them a becoming opinion of Himself, much more would He do so in the case of His mother. And since it was probable that if these words had been addressed to her by her Son, she would not readily have chosen even then to be convinced, but would in all cases have claimed the superiority as being His mother, therefore He replied as He did to them who spake to Him; otherwise He could not have led up her thoughts from His present lowliness to His future exaltation, had she expected that she should always be honored by Him as by a son, and not that He should come as her Master.</p><p>It was then from this motive that He said in this place, \"Woman, what have I to do with thee?\" and also for another reason not less pressing. What was that? It was, that His miracles might not be suspected. The request ought to have come from those who needed, not from His mother. And why so? Because what is done at the request of one's friends, great though it be, often causes offense to the spectators; but when they make the request who have the need, the miracle is free from suspicion, the praise unmixed, the benefit great. So if some excellent physician should enter a house where there were many sick, and be spoken to by none of the patients or their relations, but be directed only by his own mother, he would be suspected and disliked by the sufferers, nor would any of the patients or their attendants deem him able to exhibit anything great or remarkable. And so this was a reason why He rebuked her on that occasion, saying, \"Woman, what have I to do with thee?\" instructing her for the future not to do the like; because, though He was careful to honor His mother, yet He cared much more for the salvation of her soul, and for the doing good to the many, for which He took upon Him the flesh.</p><p>These then were the words, not of one speaking rudely to his mother, but belonging to a wise dispensation, which brought her into a right frame of mind, and provided that the miracles should be attended with that honor which was meet.<br/><i>— Homily on the Gospel of John 21</i></p><p><b>Maximus of Turin</b>: The most blessed Mary said to him, \"They have no wine.\" Jesus answered as though he were displeased. \"Woman,\" he said, \"is that my concern or yours?\" It can hardly be doubted that these were words of displeasure. However, this I think was only because his mother mentioned to him so casually the lack of earthly wine, when he had come to offer the peoples of the whole world the new chalice of eternal salvation. By his reply, \"My hour has not yet come,\" he was foretelling the most glorious hour of his passion and the wine of our redemption, which would obtain life for all. Mary was asking for a temporal favor, but Christ was preparing joys that would be eternal. Nevertheless, the Lord in his goodness did not refuse this small grace while greater graces awaited.<br/><i>— SERMON 23</i></p><p><b>Philoxenus of Mabbug</b>: It is written that three days after our Lord had returned from the wilderness, He was bidden to a feast, He, and His mother, and His brethren, and His disciples. And when wine was lacking for the guests, His mother said to Jesus, \"They have no wine,\" and she began on this occasion also to speak to Him with authority, even as a mother doth from early habit; but Jesus restrained that freedom of speech, teaching that the obligation of parental reverence had been paid by Him, and that henceforth He would not be subject unto His parents as He had been of yore. And observe what a severe rebuke He brought against that early authority thereby! \"What have I to do with thee, woman?\" The words are full of rebuke, and the whole speech is full of indignation, and rightly so, because by this speech He was giving an example to those who are perfect of not being governed by the law of natural parents when they have come out from the world in which their parents still live. For Mary stood in one rule of life, and Jesus stood in another, that is to say, she lived the life of the law, and He lived the life of the Spirit; and it was not well that He Who lived the life of the Spirit should be commanded by one who was still governed by the law.</p><p>Mary gave the command like a woman in authority, and Jesus answered her like a free man; \"They have no wine,\" said Mary, and these are words of authority, and like a mother she spake with a command. \"What have I to do with thee, O woman?\" He replied like one who was not subject unto her, and He spake as unto a strange woman who was not His mother. For He did not say, \"What hast thou to do with me, My mother?\", but, \"What hast thou to do with Me, O woman? By grace thou hast become my mother, and through Divine dispensation I have been born of thee; and I have been subject unto thee, and I have been obedient, but not because I am bound to be so to thee naturally. My beginning was not from thee, that I should receive grace from thee, for it was for thy sake that I came into being. Thou didst not become with child with suffering, neither didst thou bring me forth with the pangs of birth; thou didst not rear Me as one who was in need of rearing that I should give unto thee the reward of the fulfilling of My wants. Everything which thou didst give to Me I have given to thee. And if thou didst carry Me in thy womb, and didst grow great with Me, and didst bring Me forth, and didst care for Me, and didst bring Me up, these things took place by the power which came from Me. And that I have been obedient and subject unto thee was not a debt which I was bound to pay thee on My own behalf, but I paid the debt and I fulfilled the law on behalf of all the children who rebel against their parents. And now that the debt hath been paid, and dispensation of the law hath been fulfilled, what have I to do with thee, O woman?\"</p><p>Now this speech is like unto the words, \"Who is My mother?\" and unto that which He said to John, \"Behold thy mother!\" and again He said to Mary, \"Behold thy son!\"<br/><i>— 13 Ascetic Discourses, Discourse 8 -- First Discourse on Poverty</i></p><p><b>Romanos the Melodist</b>: But Christ seeing His mother saying, \"Grant me this request,\"<br/>At once said to her: \"What do you wish, woman, my hour has not come.\"<br/>Certain men made use of this saying as a pretext for impiety;<br/>They said that Christ, submitted to necessity,<br/>They said that He was a slave to periods of time. …</p><p>\"Now answer, my child,\" said the all-holy mother of Christ,<br/>\"Thou who dost control with measurement the periods of time, how, my son and Lord, dost Thou await a time?<br/>Thou who hast regulated the division of the seasons, how dost thou await a season?<br/>Thou who art the creator of the visible and the invisible,<br/>Thou who, as master, dost day and night regulate<br/>The ceaseless revolutions, as Thou dost will them—<br/>Thou who hast defined the years in beautifully ordered cycles—<br/>How, then, dost Thou await a time for the miracle which I ask of Thee<br/>Who hast in wisdom created all things?\"</p><p>\"I knew before you told me, revered Virgin, that the wine was just beginning to give out for them,\"<br/>The Ineffable and Merciful straightway answered His holy mother.<br/>\"I know all the concerns of your heart which you set in motion in this matter;<br/>For within yourself you reasoned as follows:<br/>'Necessity now summons my son to a miracle,<br/>And He puts it off under the pretext of \"the time.\" '<br/>Holy mother, learn now the meaning of the delay,<br/>For when you know it, I shall grant you this favor,<br/>I, who in wisdom have created all things.<br/><i>— KONTAKION ON THE MARRIAGE AT CANA 7.10-12</i></p><p><b>Romanos the Melodist</b>: \"At the time when I brought forward Heavens and the Earth and all things from a state of nonexistence,<br/>I would have been quite able at that time to arrange in order at once all that I had produced;<br/>But I introduced a certain well-regulated order.<br/>Creation was accomplished in six days—<br/>Not that I did not have the power,<br/>But in order that the chorus of angels, seeing what I did, each deed in turn,<br/>Would deify me, singing a hymn: 'Glory to Thee, Powerful One,<br/>Who hast in wisdom created all things.' …<br/>\"Mark what I say, holy one; for at this time I was willing first<br/>To announce to the Israelites and to teach them the hope of faith,<br/>In order that in the presence of miracles they might learn thoroughly who has sent me,<br/>And that they might know with certainty the glory of my Father,<br/>And his will, for He desires that in every way<br/>I be glorified along with Him by all.<br/>For what He who engendered me has done, these things I also do,<br/>Since I am consubstantial with Him and His Spirit,<br/>I, who have in wisdom created all things.<br/>\"For if they had understood all these things at the time when they saw the awesome miracles,<br/>They would understand that I am God before time, even though I have become man.<br/>But now, contrary to order, before the teaching, you have asked for miracles;<br/>And it is for this reason that I delayed a short time in answer to you:<br/>If I was waiting for the time to perform miracles,<br/>It was for this reason alone.<br/>But, since it is necessary that parents be honored by their children,<br/>I shall pay observance to you, Mother, for I am able to do all things,<br/>I, who have in wisdom created all things.\"<br/><i>— KONTAKION ON THE MARRIAGE AT CANA 7.13-16</i></p>","source_html_sha256":"dbf061693caa7d2c1d0af5b8b48c0d41e7691f152171bac92c3bb8c268ac90c3","source_module":"ECF","source_row_id":9253,"source_url":"https://www.sermonindex.net/commentary/ecf/","text_sha256":"ba997879d0ff21ebd7b41d9669237f172ce92e863aa7319c036f3450e3b398f3","translator":null,"work":null}references: [] | work_id: | origin: existing-private-derived-record | source: https://www.sermonindex.net/commentary/ecf/