mentioned before,1570 and with him many other men of ability, by whom abundant mater-
ial for our history has been left.
2. A certain one of these, in the beginning of his work against them,1571 first intimates
that he had contended with them in oral controversies.
3. He commences his work in this manner:1572
“Having for a very long and sufficient time, O beloved Avircius Marcellus,1573 been
urged by you to write a treatise against the heresy of those who are called after Miltiades,1574
1569 τὴν λεγομένην κατὰ Φρύγας αἵρεσιν. The heresy of Montanus was commonly called the Phrygian heresy
because it took its rise in Phrygia. The Latins, by a solecism, called it the Cataphrygian heresy. Its followers received
other names also, e.g. Priscillianists (from the prophetess Priscilla), and Pepuziani (from Pepuza, their
headquarters). They called themselves πνευματικοί (spiritual), and the adherents of the Church ψυχιχοί (carnal).
1570 In Bk. IV. chaps. 21, 26 and 27, and in Bk. V. chap. 5. See especially Bk. IV. chap. 27, note 1.
1571 The author of this work is unknown. Jerome (de vir. ill. 37) ascribes it to Rhodo (but see above, chap.
13, note 1). It is sometimes ascribed to Asterius Urbanus, mentioned by Eusebius in §17 below, but he was certainly
not its author (see below, note 27). Upon the date of the work, see below, note 32.
1572 The fragments of this anonymous work are given by Routh, Rel. Sac. Vol. II. p. 183 sqq., and in English
in the Ante-Nicene Fathers, Vol. VII. p. 335 sqq.
1573 ᾽Αουίρκιε, as most of the mss. read. Others have ᾽Αυίρκιε or ᾽Αβίρκιε; Nicephorus, ᾽Αβέρκιε. The name
is quite commonly written Abercius in English, and the person mentioned here is identified by many scholars
(among them Lightfoot) with Abercius, a prominent bishop of Hieropolis (not Hierapolis, as was formerly
supposed). A spurious Life of S. Abercius is given by Simeon Metaphrastes (in Migne’s Patr. Gr. CXV. 1211 sq.),
which, although of a decidedly legendary character, rests upon a groundwork of fact as proved by the discovery,
in recent years of an epitaph from Abercius’ tomb. This Abercius was bishop in the time of Marcus Aurelius,
and therefore must have held office at least twelve or fifteen years (on the date of this anonymous treatise, see
below, note 32), or, if the date given by the spurious Acts for Abercius’ visit to Rome be accepted (163 a.d.), at
least thirty years. On Abercius and Avercius, see the exhaustive note of Lightfoot, in his Apostolic Fathers, Part
II. (Ignatius and Polycarp), Vol. I. p. 477–485.
1574 εἰς τὴν τῶν κατὰ Μιλτι€δην λεγομένων αἵρεσιν. The occurrence of the name Miltiades, in this connec-
tion, is very puzzling, for we nowhere else hear of a Montanist Miltiades, while the man referred to here must
have held a very prominent place among them. It is true that it is commonly supposed that the Muratorian
Canon refers to some heretic Miltiades, but since Harnack’s discussion of the matter (see especially his Texte
und Untersuchungen, I. 1, p. 216, note) it is more than doubtful whether a Miltiades is mentioned at all in that
document. In any case the prominent position given him here is surprising, and, as a consequence, Valesius (in
his notes), Stroth, Zimmermann, Schwegler, Laemmer, and Heinichen substitute ᾽Αλκιβι€δην (who is mentioned
in chap. 3 as a prominent Montanist) for Μιλτι€δην. The mss., however, are unanimous in reading Μιλτι€δην;
and it is impossible to see how, if ᾽Αλκιβι€δην had originally stood in the text, Μιλτι€δην could have been sub-
stituted for it. It is not impossible that instead of Alcibiades in chap. 3 we should read, as Salmon suggests,
Miltiades. The occurrence of the name Alcibiades in the previous sentence might explain its substitution for
544
The Circumstances related of Montanus and his False Prophets.