Chapter XII.—The Disciples of our Saviour.
1. The names of the apostles of our Saviour are known to every one from the Gospels.199
But there exists no catalogue of the seventy disciples.200 Barnabas, indeed, is said to have
99
been one of them, of whom the Acts of the apostles makes mention in various places,201
and especially Paul in his Epistle to the Galatians.202
2. They say that Sosthenes also, who wrote to the Corinthians with Paul, was one of
them.203 This is the account of Clement204 in the fifth book of his Hypotyposes, in which
he also says that Cephas was one of the seventy disciples,205 a man who bore the same name
as the apostle Peter, and the one concerning whom Paul says, “When Cephas came to Antioch
I withstood him to his face.”206
199 See Matt. x. 2–4; Luke vi. 13–16; Mark iii. 14–19
200 See Luke x. 1–20.
201 See Acts iv. 36, xiii. 1 et passim. Clement of Alexandria (Strom. II. 20) calls Barnabas one of the Seventy.
This tradition is not in itself improbable, but we can trace it back no further than Clement. The Clementine
Recognitions and Homilies frequently mention Barnabas as an apostle active in Alexandria and in Rome. One
tradition sends him to Milan and makes him the first bishop of the church there, but the silence of Ambrose in
regard to it is a sufficient proof of its groundlessness. There is extant an apocryphal work, probably of the fifth
century, entitled Acta et Passio Barnabæ in Cypro, which relates his death by martyrdom in Cyprus. The tradition
may be true, but its existence has no weight. Barnabas came from Cyprus and labored there for at least a time.
It would be natural, therefore, to assign his death (which was necessarily martyrdom, for no Christian writer of
the early centuries could have admitted that he died a natural death) to that place.
202 Gal. ii. 1, 9, and 13.
203 Sosthenes is mentioned in 1 Cor. i. 1. From what source Eusebius drew this report in regard to him I
cannot tell. He is the first to mention it, so far as I know. A later tradition reports that he became Bishop of
Colophon, a city in Ionia. A Sosthenes is mentioned also in Acts xviii. 17, as ruler of the Jewish synagogue in
Corinth. Some wish to identify the two, supposing the latter to have been afterward converted, but in this case
of course he cannot have been one of the Seventy. Eusebius’ tradition is one in regard to whose value we can
form no opinion.
204 On Clement and his works see Bk. V. chap. 11, note 1, and Bk. VI. chap. 13.
205 Clement is, so far as I know, the first to make this distinction between Peter the Apostle, and Cephas, one
of the Seventy. The reason for the invention of a second Peter in the post-apostolic age is easy to understand as
resulting from the desire to do away with the conflict between two apostles. This Cephas appears frequently in
later traditions and is commemorated in the Menology of Basil on December 9, and in the Armenian calendar
on September 25. In the Ecclesiastical Canons he is made one of the twelve apostles, and distinguished from
Peter.
206 Gal. ii. 11.
The Disciples of our Saviour.
154
The Disciples of our Saviour.