arrived in Scotland. It was extensively read by men of speculative minds; and, though
presenting a view of the subject wholly new, gave great satisfaction to men of all classes.
Lord Kaimes and his friends, having read the work of Mr. Edwards, endeavoured to show
that the view of liberty and necessity, in the Freedom of the Will, was substantially the same
with that given by his lordship. Mr. Erskine apprized Mr. Edwards of this fact. In the follow-
ing letter, the latter barely alludes to the work of Lord Kaimes, as a work of corrupt tendency.
In a subsequent letter to his friends, written in the summer of the following year, and now
appended to the Treatise on the Freedom of the Will, 66 he examines the views of liberty
and necessity by his lordship, shows their entire discordance with his own views, as exhibited
in the Freedom of the Will, and exposes their inconsistency, not only with reason but with
each other. This letter, from a sense of justice to its author, was immediately published, in
the form of a pamphlet, by Mr. Erskine, and produced a universal conviction, that Lord
Kaimes had wholly misunderstood the view taken of liberty and necessity by Mr. Edwards;
clxvii
and that his own views of it were at war, alike with reason and revelation. Indeed, his lordship
himself appears to have been of the same opinion; for, in a subsequent edition, the Essay
on Liberty and Necessity is said to have been much changed, as to present essentially different
views of those important subjects.
“To the Rev. John Erskine, Minister of the Gospel, at Culross, Scotland.
Stockbridge, Dec. 11, 1755
rev. and dear sir,
I last wrote to you July 24th, 1755. Since that I received a letter from you, dated June
23, 1755, together with the Essays on the Principles of Morality and Natural Religion,* from
Mr. Hogg, and the Analysis of the Moral and Religious Sentiments of Sopho, from yourself.
I thank you for your letter and present, and shall write a letter of thanks to Mr. Hogg, for
his present by your hand, added to former instances of his generosity. I had before read that
book of Essays, having borrowed Mr. Bellamy’s, and also that book of Mr. David Hume’s,
which you speak of. I am glad of an opportunity to read such corrupt books, especially when
written by men of considerable genius; that I may have an idea of the notions that prevail
in our nation. You say that some people say, that Lord Kaimes’s being made a Lord of Session
would have been prevented, if Chancellor Hardwick and Archbishop Herring had seasonably
seen his book. I should be glad to know who this Chancellor Hardwick is, and what is his
character. By your mentioning him in such a manner, I am ready to suppose he may be, in
some respects, of good character; and it is a matter of thankfulness, if a man of good character,
and a friend to religion, be Lord Chancellor.
66 See vol. I. pp. 89-98. Lord Kaimes had a much higher reputation, as a writer, fifty years ago than at present.
The perusal of his Essay on Liberty and Necessity, and of the remarks upon it, in the letter of Mr. Edwards, here
referred to, will inevitably lead to the conviction, that, as a metaphysician, he was neither accurate nor profound.
349
CHAPTER XXIII. Sickness of Mr. Edwards. “God's Last End in Creation.” “Nature…