Letter LXXXIII.
(a.d. 405.)
362
To My Lord Alypius Most Blessed, My Brother and Colleague, Beloved and Longed for
With Sincere Veneration, and to the Brethren that are with Him, Augustin and the Brethren
with Him Send Greeting in the Lord.
1. The sorrow of the members of the Church at Thiave prevents my heart from having
any rest until I hear that they have been brought again to be of the same mind towards you
as they formerly were; which must be accomplished without delay. For if the apostle was
concerned about one individual, “lest perhaps such an one should be swallowed up with
overmuch sorrow,” adding in the same context the words, “lest Satan should get an advantage
of us, for we are not ignorant of his devices,”2074 how much more does it become us to act
with caution, lest we cause similar grief to a whole flock, and especially one composed of
persons who have lately been reconciled to the Catholic Church, and whom I can upon no
account forsake! As, however, the short time at our disposal did not permit us so to take
counsel together as to arrive at a mature and satisfactory decision, may it please your Holiness
to accept in this letter the finding which commended itself most to me when I had long re-
flected upon the matter since we parted; and if you approve of it, let the enclosed letter,2075
which I have written to them in the name of both of us, be sent to them without delay.
2. You proposed that they should have the one half [of the property left by Honoratus],
and that the other half should be made up to them by me from such resources as might be
at my disposal. I think, however, that if the whole property had been taken from them, men
might reasonably have said that we had taken the great pains in this matter which we have
done, for the sake of justice, not for pecuniary advantage. But when we concede to them
one half, and in that way settle with them by a compromise, it will be manifest that our
anxiety has been only about the money; and you see what harm must follow from this. For,
on the one hand, we shall be regarded by them as having taken away one half of a property
to which we had no claim; and, on the other hand, they will be regarded by us as dishonour-
ably and unjustly consenting to accept aid from one half of a property of which the whole
belonged to the poor. For your remark, “We must beware lest, in our efforts to obtain a
right adjustment of a difficult question, we cause more serious wounds,” applies with no
less force if the half be conceded to them. For those whose turning from the world to mon-
astic life we desire to secure, will, for the sake of this half of their private estates, be disposed
to find some excuse for putting off the sale of these, in order that their case may be dealt
with according to this precedent. Moreover, would it not be strange, if, in a question like
this, where much may be said on both sides, a whole community should, through our not
2074 2 Cor. ii. 7, 11.
2075 This letter has not been preserved.
To Alypius
807
To Alypius