evil imagination put into man? And he answered, From the hour that he is formed.” And in Pool’s Synopsis it
is added, from Grotius, “So Rabbi Salomon interprets Gen. viii. 21. The imagination of man’s heart, is evil from
his youth, of its being evil from the time that he is taken out of his mother’s bowels.” Aben-Ezra thus interprets
Psal. li. 5. “I was shapen in iniquity, and in sin did my mother conceive me; that evil concupiscence is implanted
in the heart from childhood, as if he were formed in it; and by my mother, he understands Eve, who did not
bear children till she had sinned. And so Kafvenaki says, How shall I avoid sinning? My ORIGINAL is corrupt,
and from thence are those sins. So Manasseh Ben Israel, from this place (Psal. li. 5.) concludes, that not only
David, but all mankind, ever since sin was introduced into the world, do sin from their original. To this purpose
is the answer of Rabbi Hakkadosch which there is an account of in the Talmud. From what time does concupis-
cence rule over man? From the very moment of his first formation, or from his nativity? Ans. From his forma-
tion.”’—Pool’s Synops. in Loc. On these things I observe, there is the greatest reason to suppose, that these old
rabbies of the Jewish nation, who give such heed to the tradition of the elders, would never have received this
doctrine of original sin, had it not been delivered down to them from their forefathers. For it is a doctrine very
disagreeable to those practical principles and notions, wherein the religion of the unbelieving Jews most funda-
mentally differs from the religion maintained among Christians: particularly their notion of justification by
their own righteousness, and privileges as the children of Abraham. &c. without standing in need of any satis-
faction, by the sufferings of the Messiah. On which account the modern Jews do now universally reject the
doctrine of original sin, and corruption of nature: as Stapferus observes. And it is not at all likely, that the ancient
Jews, if no such doctrine had been received by tradition from the fathers would have taken it up from the
Christians, whom they had in such great contempt and enmity; especially as it is a doctrine so peculiarly agreeable
to the christian notion of the spiritual salvation of Jesus, and so contrary to their carnal notions of the Messiah,
and of his salvation and kingdom, and so contrary to their opinion of themselves; and a doctrine, which men
in general are so apt to be prejudiced against. And besides, these rabbies do expressly refer to the opinion of
their forefathers; as R. Manasseh says, “according to the opinion of the ancients, none are subject to death, but
those which have sinned; for where there is no sin, there is no death.” Stapfer. tom. iii. p. 37, 38. But where we
have more direct evidence, that the doctrine of original sin was truly a received doctrine among the ancient
Jews, even before the coming of Christ. This appears by ancient Jewish writings, which were written before
Christ: as, in the apocrypha, 2 Esdras iii. 21. “For the first Adam, bearing a wicked heart, transgressed, and was
overcome: and so be all they that are born of him. Thus infirmity was made permanent; and the law also in the
heart of the people, with the malignity of the root; so that the good departed away, and the evil abode still.” 2
Esdras iv. 30. “For the grain of evil seed hath been sown in the heart of Adam, from the beginning; and how
much ungodliness hath it brought up unto this time? And how much shall it yet bring forth, till the time of
threshing shall come?” And chap. vii. 46. “It had been better, not to have given the earth unto Adam; or else,
when it was given to him, to have restrained him from sinning; for what profit is it, for men now in this present
time, to live in heaviness, and after death to look for punishment? O thou Adam, what hast thou done? For
though it was thou that sinned, thou art not fallen alone, but we all that came of thee.” And we read Eccl. xxv.
24. “Of the woman came the beginning of sin, and through her we all die.” As this doctrine of original corruption
was constantly maintained in the church of God from the beginning; so from thence, in all probability, as well
as from the evidennce of it in universal experience, it was, that the wiser heathens maintained the like doctrine.
1182
CHAPTER IV. Several other Objections answered.