Son is in a manner circumscribed, the beginning of His being begotten limiting His life at
the commencement, and preventing it from being coextensive with the eternity of the
Father, so that His life also is to be regarded as defective; and the Father was not always what
He now is and is said to be, but, having been something else before, He afterwards determined
that He would be a Father, or rather that He would be so called. For not even of the Son was
He rightly called Father, but of a creature supposititiously invested with the title of son. And
every way, say they, the younger is of necessity inferior to the elder, the finite to the eternal,
that which is begotten by the will of the begetter, to the begetter himself, both in power, and
dignity, and nature, and precedence due to age, and all other prerogatives of respect. But
how can we justly dignify with the honours due to the true God that which is wanting in
the perfection of the diviner attributes? Thus they would establish the doctrine that one who
is limited in power, and wanting in the perfection of life, and subject to a superior, and doing
nothing of himself but what is sanctioned by the authority of the more powerful, is in no
divine honour and consideration, but that, while we call him God, we are employing a term
empty of all grandeur in its significance. And since such statements as these, when stripped
of their plausible dress, move indignation and make the hearer shudder at their strangeness
(for who can tolerate an evil counsellor nakedly and unadvisably urging the overthrow of
the majesty of Christ?), they therefore try to pervert foolish hearers with these foreign notions
by enveloping their malignant and insidious arguments in a number of seductive fallacies.
For after laying down such premises as might naturally lead the mind of the hearers in the
desired direction, they leave the hearer to draw his conclusion for himself.
For after saying that the Only-begotten God is not the same in essence with the true
Father, and after sophistically inferring this from the opposition between generate and un-
generate, they work in silence to the conclusion, their impiety prevailing by the natural
course of inference. And as the poisoner makes his drug acceptable to his victim by sweet-
ening its deadliness with honey, and, as for himself, has only to offer it, while the drug in-
sinuating itself into the vitals without further action on the part of the poisoner does its
deadly work,—so, too, do our opponents act. For qualifying their pernicious teaching with
their sophistical refinements, as with honey, when they have infused into the mind of the
hearer the venomous fallacy that God the Only-begotten is not very God, they cause all the
rest to be inferred without saying a word. For when they are persuaded that He is not truly
256
God, it follows as a matter of course that no other Divine attribute is truly applicable. For
if He is truly neither Son nor God, except by an abuse of terms, then the other names which
are given to Him in Holy Scripture are a divergence from the truth. For the one thing cannot
be predicated of Him with truth, and the other be destitute of it; but they must needs follow
one another, so that, if He be truly God, it follows that He is Judge and King, and that His
several attributes are such as they are described, while, if His godhead be falsely asserted,
neither will the truth hold respecting any of His other attributes. They, then, having been
486
Answer to Eunomius' Second Book.