resistances, just like it? And it might as reasonably be asked, Why, when God first caused
it to thunder, he caused that individual sound then to be made, and not another just like it?
Why did he make choice of this very sound, and reject all the infinite number of other pos-
sible sounds just like it, but numerically differing from it, and all differing one from another?
I think, every body must be sensible of the absurdity and nonsense of what is supposed in
such inquiries. And, if we calmly attend to the matter, we shall be convinced, that all such
kind of objections as I am answering, are founded on nothing but the imperfection of our
manner of conceiving things, and the obscureness of language, and great want of clearness
and precision in the signification of terms.
If any should find fault with this reasoning, that it is going a great length into metaphys-
ical niceties and subtilties; I answer, the objection to which they are a reply, is a metaphys-
ical subtilty, and must be treated according to the nature of it. 145
II. Another thing alleged is, that innumerable things which are determined by the Divine
Will, and chosen and done by God rather than others, differ from those that are not chosen
in so inconsiderable a manner, that it would be unreasonable to suppose the difference to
be of any consequence, or that there is any superior fitness or goodness, mat God can have
respect to in the determination.
To which I answer; it is impossible for us to determine, with any certainty or evidence,
that because the difference is very small, and appears to us of no consideration, therefore
there is absolutely no superior goodness, and no valuable end, which can be proposed by
the Creator and Governor of the world, in ordering such a difference. The forementioned
author mentions many instances. One is, there being one atom in the whole universe more,
or less. But, I think, it would be unreasonable to suppose, that God made one atom in vain,
or without any end or motive. He made not one atom, but what was a work of his Almighty
Power, as much as the whole globe of the earth, and requires as much of a constant exertion
of Almighty Power to uphold it; and was made and is upheld with understanding and design,
as much as if no other had been made but that. And it would be as unreasonable to suppose,
that he made it without any thing really aimed at in so doing, as much as to suppose, that
he made the planet Jupiter without aim or design.
It is possible, that the most minute effects of the Creator’s power, the smallest assignable
difference between the things which God has made, may be attended, in the whole series of
events, and the whole compass and extent of their influence, with very great and important
consequences. If the laws of motion, and gravitation, laid down by Sir Isaac Newton, hold
universally, there is not one atom, nor the least assignable part of an atom, but what has
influence, every moment, throughout the whole material universe, to cause every part to be
145 “For men to have recourse to subtilties in raising difficulties, and then complain, that they should be
taken off by minutely examining these subtilties, is a strange kind of procedure.
722
SECTION VIII. Some further objections against the moral Necessity of God's…