170
5. And certain men have lately brought forward other wordy and lengthy writings under
his name, containing dialogues of Peter and Apion.937 But no mention has been made of
these by the ancients; for they do not even preserve the pure stamp of apostolic orthodoxy.
The acknowledged writing of Clement is well known. We have spoken also of the works of
Ignatius and Polycarp.938
937 There are extant a number of Pseudo-Clementine writings of the third and following centuries, the chief
among which purports to contain a record made by Clement of discourses of the apostle Peter, and an account
of Clement’s family history and of his travels with Peter, constituting, in fact, a sort of didactico-historical romance.
This exists now in three forms (the Homilies, Recognitions, and Epitome), all of which are closely related; though
whether the first two (the last is simply an abridgment of the first) are drawn from a common original, or
whether one of them is the original of the other, is not certain. The works are more or less Ebionitic in character,
and play an important part in the history of early Christian literature. For a careful discussion of them, see Sal-
mon’s article Clementine Literature, in the Dict. of Christian Biography; and for the literature of the subject,
which is very extensive, see especially Schaff’s Church History, II. p. 435 sq. The fourth, fifth, and sixth books of
the Homilies contain extended conversations purporting to have been held between Clement and Apion, the
famous antagonist of the Jews (see Bk. II. chap. 5, note 5). It is quite possible that the “wordy and lengthy writings,
containing dialogues of Peter and Apion,” which Eusebius refers to here may be identical with the Homilies, in
which case we must suppose Eusebius’ language to be somewhat inexact; for the dialogues in the Homilies are
between Clement and Apion, not between Peter and Apion. It seems more probable, however, when we realize
the vast number of works of a similar character which were in circulation during the third and subsequent
centuries, that Eusebius refers here to another work, belonging to the same general class, which is now lost. If
such a work existed, it may well have formed a basis for the dialogues between Clement and Apion given in the
Homilies. In the absence of all further evidence of such a work, we must leave the matter quite undecided. It is
not necessary here to enumerate the other Pseudo-Clementine works which are still extant. Compare Schaff’s
Church History, II. 648 sq. Clement’s name was a favorite one with pseudographers of the early Church, and
works of all kinds were published under his name. The most complete collection of these spurious works is
found in Migne’s Patr. Græc. Vols. I. and II.
938 In chap. 36, above.
368
The Epistle of Clement and the Writings falsely ascribed to him.