Chapter 2.—On the Difference in the Health of Twins.
Cicero says that the famous physician Hippocrates has left in writing that he had sus-
pected that a certain pair of brothers were twins, from the fact that they both took ill at once,
and their disease advanced to its crisis and subsided in the same time in each of them.190
Posidonius the Stoic, who was much given to astrology, used to explain the fact by supposing
that they had been born and conceived under the same constellation. In this question the
conjecture of the physician is by far more worthy to be accepted, and approaches much
nearer to credibility, since, according as the parents were affected in body at the time of
copulation, so might the first elements of the fœtuses have been affected, so that all that was
necessary for their growth and development up till birth having been supplied from the
body of the same mother, they might be born with like constitutions. Thereafter, nourished
in the same house, on the same kinds of food, where they would have also the same kinds
of air, the same locality, the same quality of water,—which, according to the testimony of
medical science, have a very great influence, good or bad, on the condition of bodily
health,—and where they would also be accustomed to the same kinds of exercise, they would
have bodily constitutions so similar that they would be similarly affected with sickness at
the same time and by the same causes. But, to wish to adduce that particular position of
the stars which existed at the time when they were born or conceived as the cause of their
being simultaneously affected with sickness, manifests the greatest arrogance, when so many
beings of most diverse kinds, in the most diverse conditions, and subject to the most diverse
events, may have been conceived and born at the same time, and in the same district, lying
under the same sky. But we know that twins do not only act differently, and travel to very
different places, but that they also suffer from different kinds of sickness; for which Hippo-
crates would give what is in my opinion the simplest reason, namely, that, through diversity
of food and exercise, which arises not from the constitution of the body, but from the inclin-
ation of the mind, they may have come to be different from each other in respect of health.
Moreover, Posidonius, or any other asserter of the fatal influence of the stars, will have
86
enough to do to find anything to say to this, if he be unwilling to im pose upon the minds
of the uninstructed in things of which they are ignorant. But, as to what they attempt to
make out from that very small interval of time elapsing between the births of twins, on ac-
count of that point in the heavens where the mark of the natal hour is placed, and which
they call the “horoscope,” it is either disproportionately small to the diversity which is found
in the dispositions, actions, habits, and fortunes of twins, or it is disproportionately great
when compared with the estate of twins, whether low or high, which is the same for both
of them, the cause for whose greatest difference they place, in every case, in the hour on
190 This fact is not recorded in any of the extant works of Hippocrates or Cicero. Vives supposes it may have
found place in Cicero’s book, De Fato.
On the Difference in the Health of Twins.
211
On the Difference in the Health of Twins.