essence. I need not mention taste or smell, which apprehend respectively savour and scent.
Hearing perceives sounds and voices, which have no affinity with earth. They must then
say that they have found out the earth’s essence by reason. What? In what part of Scripture?
A tradition from what saint?329
“In a word, if any one wishes to realise the truth of what I am urging, let him ask himself
this question; when he wishes to understand anything about God, does he approach the
meaning of ‘the unbegotten’? I for my part see that, just as when we extend our thought
over the ages that are yet to come, we say that the life bounded by no limit is without end,
so is it when we contemplate in thought the ages of the past, and gaze on the infinity of the
life of God as we might into some unfathomable ocean. We can conceive of no beginning
from which He originated: we perceive that the life of God always transcends the bounds
of our intelligence; and so we call that in His life which is without origin, unbegotten.330
The meaning of the unbegotten is the having no origin from without.”331 As Eunomius
made ingenerateness the essence of the Divine, so, with the object of establishing the contrast
between Father and Son, he represented the being begotten to indicate the essence of the
Son.332 God, said Eunomius, being ingenerate, could never admit of generation. This
statement, Basil points out, may be understood in either of two ways. It may mean that in-
generate nature cannot be subjected to generation. It may mean that ingenerate nature
cannot generate. Eunomius, he says, really means the latter, while he makes converts of the
multitude on the lines of the former. Eunomius makes his real meaning evident by what
he adds to his dictum, for, after saying “could never admit of generation,” he goes on, “so
as to impart His own proper nature to the begotten.”333 As in relation to the Father, so now
in relation to the Son, Basil objects to the term. Why “begotten”?334 Where did he get this
word? From what teaching? From what prophet? Basil nowhere finds the Son called “be-
gotten” in Scripture.335 We read that the Father begat, but nowhere that the Son was a be-
gotten thing. “Unto us a child is born,336 unto us a Son is given.”337 But His name is not
begotten thing but “angel of great counsel.”338 If this word had indicated the essence of the
329 Id. i. 13.
330 τοῦτο τὸ ἄναρχον τῆς ζωῆς ἀγέννητον προσειρήκαμεν.
331 Id. i. 16.
332 τὸ γέννημα. Id. ii. 6.
333 Id. i. 16.
334 γέννημα, i.e., “thing begotten;” the distinction between this substantive and the scriptural adjective
μονογενής must be borne in mind.
335 Id. ii. 6.
336 LXX., ἐγεννήθη.
337 Is. ix. 6.
338 Id. LXX.
58
Dogmatic.