lxxvi
persons, the advantages they had for information, or the disadvantages they have been
under, and what has been in their circumstances that might mislead the judgment—the
principles that have been instilled into them—the instructions they have received from
those, of whose piety and wisdom they have had a high opinion, which might misguide the
judgment of persons of real honesty, and sincerity, and tender conscience—the example of
others—the diversity of opinion among ministers—the general state of things in the land—the
character of the persons themselves—and the manner of their behaviour in the particular
affair in debate.
Now, Sir, with regard to those persons that have gone from you, to W—however you
may look upon their behaviour herein as very disorderly, yet, if you suppose (the case being
considered with all its circumstances) that there was any room for charity, that it might be
through infirmity, ignorance, and error of judgment, so that they might be truly conscientious
in it; that is, might really believe it to be their duty, and what God required of them, to do
as they have done; you would, I imagine, by no means think, that they ought to be proceeded
with, in the use of such means as are proper to be used with contumacious offenders, or
those that are stubborn and obstinate in scandalous vice and wilful wickedness; or that you
would think it proper to proceed with persons, towards whom there is this room left for
charity, that possibly they may be honest and truly conscientious, acting as persons afraid
to offend God, so as to cut them off from the communion of the Lord, and cast them forth
into the visible kingdom of Satan, to be as harlots and publicans.
Now, it may be well to examine, whether it can positively be determined, when all things
are taken into consideration with respect to these persons, who have absented themselves
from your assembly, that it is not possible in their case, that this might really be their honest
judgment, that it was their duty to do so, and that God required it of them, and that they
should greatly expose the welfare of their own souls, in attending no other public worship
but that in your congregation. I suppose these persons are not much versed in casuistical
divinity. They are of the common people, whose judgments, in all nations and ages, are ex-
ceedingly led and swayed. They are not very capable of viewing things in the extent of their
consequences, and of estimating things in their true weight and importance. And you know,
dear Sir, the state that things have been in, in the country. You know what opinions have
lately prevailed, and have been maintained and propagated, by those that have been lifted
up to heaven, in their reputation for piety and great knowledge in spiritual things, with a
great part of the people of New England. I do not pretend to know what has influenced these
people, in particular; but I think, under these circumstances, it would be no strange thing,
if great numbers of the common people in the country, who are really conscientious, and
concerned to be accepted with God, and to take the best course for the good of their souls,
should really think in their hearts that God requires them to attend the ministry of those
that are called New Light Ministers, and that it would be dangerous to their souls, and what
150
Chapter XIII. First Interview with David Brainerd--Separations From Churches--Letter…