of expression an objection against one who is guilty of impiety. I will just add to my invest-
igation this remark. If the Spirit has “gone above” all the creations of the Son, (for I will use
his own ungrammatical and senseless phrase, or rather, to make things clearer, I will present
his idea in my own language) if he transcends all things wrought by the Son, the Holy Spirit
cannot be ranked with the rest of the creation; and if, as Eunomius says, he surpasses them
by virtue of priority of birth, he must needs confess, in the case of the rest of creation, that
the objects which are first in order of production are more to be esteemed than those which
come after them. Now the creation of the irrational animals was prior to that of man. Ac-
cordingly he will of course declare that the irrational nature is more honourable than rational
existence. So too, according to the argument of Eunomius, Cain will be proved superior to
Abel, in that he was before him in time of birth, and so the stars will be shown to be lower
and of less excellence than all the things that grow out of the earth; for these last sprang
from the earth on the third day, and all the stars are recorded by Moses to have been created
on the fourth. Well, surely no one is such a simpleton as to infer that the grass of the earth
is more to be esteemed than the marvels of the sky, on the ground of its precedence in time,
or to award the meed to Cain over Abel, or to place below the irrational animals man who
came into being later than they. So there is no sense in our author’s contention that the
nature of the Holy Spirit is superior to that of the creatures that came into being subsequently,
on the ground that He came into being before they did. And now let us see what he who
separates Him from fellowship with the Son is prepared to concede to the glory of the
Spirit: “For he too,” he says, “being one, and first and alone, and surpassing all the creations
of the Son in essence and dignity of nature, accomplishing every operation and all teaching
according to the good pleasure of the Son, being sent by Him, and receiving from Him, and
declaring to those who are instructed, and guiding into truth.” He speaks of the Holy Ghost
as “accomplishing every operation and all teaching.” What operation? Does he mean that
which the Father and the Son execute, according to the word of the Lord Himself Who
“hitherto worketh487” man’s salvation, or does he mean some other? For if His work is that
named, He has assuredly the same power and nature as Him Who works it, and in such an
one difference of kind from Deity can have no place. For just as, if anything should perform
the functions of fire, shining and warming in precisely the same way, it is itself certainly
fire, so if the Spirit does the works of the Father, He must assuredly be acknowledged to be
of the same nature with Him. If on the other hand He operates something else than our
salvation, and displays His operation in a contrary direction, He will thereby be proved to
be of a different nature and essence. But Eunomius’ statement itself bears witness that the
Spirit quickeneth in like manner with the Father and the Son. Accordingly, from the identity
of operations it results assuredly that the Spirit is not alien from the nature of the Father
487 S. John v. 17
254
Lastly he displays at length the folly of Eunomius, who at times speaks…