were not enough to prove his impiety, he has a piece of profanity in reserve in the phrase
that follows, when he terms the Son “not uncreate.” In what sense then does he call Him
Who is not uncreate “very Son”? For if it is meet to call Him Who is not uncreate “very
Son,” then of course the heaven is “very Son;” for it too is “not uncreate.” So the sun too is
“very Son,” and all that the creation contains, both small and great, are of course entitled
to the appellation of “very Son.” And in what sense does He call Him Who has come into
being “Only-begotten”? For all things that come into being are unquestionably in brotherhood
with each other, so far, I mean, as their coming into being is concerned. And from whom
did He come into being? For assuredly all things that have ever come into being did so from
the Son. For thus did John testify, saying, “All things were made by Him363.” If then the
117
Son also came into being, according to Eunomius’ creed, He is certainly ranked in the class
of things which have come into being. If then all things that came into being were made by
Him, and the Word is one of the things that came into being, who is so dull as not to draw
from these premises the absurd conclusion that our new creed-monger makes out the Lord
of creation to have been His own work, in saying in so many words that the Lord and Maker
of all creation is “not uncreate”? Let him tell us whence he has this boldness of assertion.
From what inspired utterance? What evangelist, what apostle ever uttered such words as
these? What prophet, what lawgiver, what patriarch, what other person of all who were di-
vinely moved by the Holy Ghost, whose voices are preserved in writing, ever originated
such a statement as this? In the tradition of the faith delivered by the Truth we are taught
to believe in Father, Son, and Holy Spirit. If it were right to believe that the Son was created,
how was it that the Truth in delivering to us this mystery bade us believe in the Son, and
not in the creature? and how is it that the inspired Apostle, himself adoring Christ, lays it
down that they who worship the creature besides the Creator are guilty of idolatry364? For,
were the Son created, either he would not have worshipped Him, or he would have refrained
from classing those who worship the creature along with idolaters, lest he himself should
appear to be an idolater, in offering adoration to the created. But he knew that He Whom
he adored was God over all365, for so he terms the Son in his Epistle to the Romans. Why
then do those who divorce the Son from the essence of the Father, and call Him creature,
bestow on Him in mockery the fictitious title of Deity, idly conferring on one alien from
true Divinity the name of “God,” as they might confer it on Bel or Dagon or the Dragon?
Let those, therefore, who affirm that He is created, acknowledge that He is not God at all,
363 S. John i. 3
364 Rom. i. 25, where παρὰ τὸν κτίσαντα may be better translated “besides the Creator,” or “rather than the
Creator,” than as in the A.V.
365 Rom. ix. 5.
223
Gregory again discusses the generation of the Only-Begotten, and other different…