CHAP. XIII. CHRISTIAN RELIGION. 177
first, and I am the last ; and beside me there is no God,"
(Is. xliv. 6.) We would also do well to ponder the words of
Jeremiah, " The gods that have not made the heavens and the
earth, even they shall perish from the earth and from under
these heavens," (Jer. x. 11 ;) whence it follows conversely,
that He whose divinity Isaiah repeatedly proves from the
creation of the world, is none other than the Son of God.
And how is it possible that the Creator, who gives to all,
should not be of himself, but should borrow his essence from
another? Whosoever says that the Son was essentiated
by the Father,1 denies his self-existence. Against this,
however, the Holy Spirit protests, when he calls him Jeho
vah. On the supposition, then, that the whole essence is in
the Father only, the essence becomes divisible, or is denied to
the Son, who, being thus robbed of his essence, will be only
a titular God. If we are to believe these triflers, divine
essence belongs to the Father only, on the ground that he is
sole God, and essentiator of the Son. In this way, the divinity
of the Son will be something abstracted2 from the essence
of God, or the derivation of a part from the whole. On the
same principle it must also be conceded, that the Spirit
belongs to the Father only. For if the derivation is from the
primary essence which is proper to none but the Father, the
Spirit cannot justly be deemed the Spirit of the Son. This
view, however, is refuted by the testimony of Paul, when he
makes the Spirit common both to Christ and the Father.
Moreover, if the Person of the Father is expunged from
the Trinity, in what will he differ from the Son and Spirit,
except in being the only God ? They confess that Christ
is God, and that he differs from the Father. If he differs,
there must be some mark of distinction between them.
Those who place it in the essence, manifestly reduce the
true divinity of Christ to nothing, since divinity cannot
exist without essence, and indeed without entire essence.3
1 The French adds, "(puisque tels abuseurs forgent des noms centre
nature ;)" — (for these perverters forge names against nature.)
2 The French is, " tire comme par un alambic ; " — extracted as by an alembic.
3 See Bernard, Serm. 80, super Cantica., on the heresy of Gilbert, Bishop of Poictiers.
VOL. I. M