CHURCHMEN AND STATESMEN
should a king in England, who had himself taken and broken
the Covenant, dare to impose upon Scotland a system of church
government which, whatever its merits, was opposed to the
obvious wishes of the people as a whole. And, after all, these
men paid for their opinions with their lives; well did they
know the risk they ran, but they held to their faith in spite
of all. It is they, and not their adversaries, however tolerant
the latter were in theory, who possess a moral position of real
strength. And they got their reward, for out of the clash of
contending faiths sprang the precious spark of toleration, and
after 1689 Scotland slowly began to become something like
a settled country.
Neither in Church nor State, however, was strife yet dead,
and in the two greatest political upheavals of the eighteenth
century conspicuous parts were played by alumni of our Uni-
versity. It is easy to sneer at "Charlie o'er the waterism,"
but the spectacle of these poor Highlanders giving a generous
love to a recipient sometimes unworthy, asking no return
for the sacrifice of everything, is one of the noblest in history.
Not all who took part in the '15 and the '45 were so
disinterested, but despite all their faults we may be proud
of our loyal Jacobites—Robertson of Strowan, who led five
hundred of his name on the field of SherifFmuir ; Tullibardine,
who unfurled the Prince's standard at Glenfinnan. The leaders,
possibly the cause itself, may not have been irreproachable,
but the men were brave and true.
Culloden is long fought, and since then our country has
been free from internecine warfare ; its pages are no longer
gay with the bright figures of armed warriors nor dark with
the misery of hopeless suffering. St. Andrews students are
no more called upon to play the same stirring parts as those
acted by their predecessors, but still there has gone forth
from our midst a steady stream of men who have served their
89