370 INSTITUTES OF THE BOOK II.
Although this argument is taken from Aristotle, I admit that
it is also used by Chrysostom and Jerome. Jerome, how
ever, does not disguise that it was familiar to the Pelagians.
He even quotes their words, " If grace acts in us, grace, and
not we who do the work, will be crowned," (Hieron. in Ep. ad Ctesiphont. et Dialog. /.) With regard to punishment, I
answer, that it is properly inflicted on those by whom the
guilt is contracted. What matters it whether you sin with
a free or an enslaved judgment, so long as you sin voluntarily,
especially when man is proved to be a sinner because he is
under the bondage of sin? In regard to the rewards of
righteousness, is there any great absurdity in acknowledging
that they depend on the kindness of God rather than our own
merits ? How often do we meet in Augustine with this ex
pression, — " God crowns not our merits but his own gifts ; and
the name of reward is given not to what is due to our merits,
but to the recompense of grace previously bestowed ?" Some seem to think there is acuteness in the remark, that there
is no place at all for the mind, if good works do not spring
from free will as their proper source ; but in thinking this so
very unreasonable they are widely mistaken. Augustine does
not hesitate uniformly to describe as necessary the very
thing which they count it impious to acknowledge. Thus
he asks, " What is human merit ? He who came to bestow
not due recompense but free grace, though himself free from
sin, and the giver of freedom, found all men sinners," (Au-
gustin. in Psal. xxxi.) Again, " If you are to receive your
due, you must be punished. What then is done ? God has
not rendered you due punishment, but bestows upon you
unmerited grace. If you wish to be an alien from grace,
boast your merits," (in Psal. Ixx.) Again, "You are
nothing in yourself, sin is yours, merit God's. Punishment is your due ; and when the reward shall come, God shall
crown his own gifts, not your merits," (Ep. Hi.) To the same effect he elsewhere says, (De Verb. Apostol. Serm. xv.,)
that grace is not of merit, but merit of grace. And shortly
after he concludes, that God by his gifts anticipates all our
merit, that he may thereby manifest his own merit, and give
what is absolutely free, because he sees nothing in us that can