Concerning the other difficulty you mention relating to the verifying of Rom. viii. 20.
“All things shall work together for good,” &c. in a saint that falls under backsliding and
spiritual decays, &c. it seems to be a matter of some difficulty to understand exactly how
this is to be taken, and how far it may from hence be inferred, that the temptations the saints
meet with from Satan, and an evil world, and their own declensions and sins, shall surely
work for their good. However, since you desire my thoughts, I would express them, such
as they are, as follows.
In order rightly to state this matter, there are two things may be laid down, as positions
of certain and indubitable truth concerning this doctrine of the apostle.
First, The meaning cannot be that God’s dispensations and disposals towards each saint
are the best for him, most tending to his happiness, of all that are possible: or that all things
that are ordered for him, or done by God with respect to him, are in all respects better for
him than any thing else that God could have ordered or done, issuing in the highest good
and happiness, that it is possible he should be brought to; for that would be as much as to
say, that God will bestow on every one of his elect, as much happiness as he can (confer,)
in the utmost exercise of his omnipotence, and this sets aside all these different degrees of
grace and holiness here, and glory hereafter, which he bestows according to his sovereign
pleasure.
All things may work together for good to the saints. All may be of benefit to them, and
may have a concurring tendency to their happiness, and may all finally issue in it, and yet
not tend to or issue in the highest degree of good and happiness possible. There is a certain
measure of holiness and happiness, that each one of the elect is eternally appointed to, and
all things that relate to him work together to bring to pass this appointed measure of good.
The text and context speak of God’s eternal purpose of good to the elect, predestinating
them to a conformity to his Son in holiness and happiness; and the implicit reasoning of
the apostle leads us to suppose that all things will purely concur to bring to effect God’s
eternal purpose. And therefore from his reasoning it may be inferred, that all things will
tend to and work together to bring to pass, that degree of good that God has purposed to
bestow upon them, and not any more. And indeed it would be in itself unreasonable to
suppose any thing else but this; inasmuch as God is the supreme orderer of all things,
doubtless all things shall be so ordered, that with one consent, they shall help to bring to
pass his ends, aims, and purposes; but surely not to bring to pass what he does not aim at,
and never intended. God in his government of the world is carrying on his own designs in
every thing; but he is not carrying on that which is not his design, and therefore there is no
need of supposing, that all the circumstances, means, and advantages of every saint, are the
best in every respect that God could have ordered for him, or that there could have been no
circumstances or means that he could have been the subject of, that would with God’s usual
blessing have issued in his greater good. Every saint is as it were a living stone, that in this
1486
LETTER I. To Mr. Gillespie, in answer to objections.