§4. He shows the falsehood of Eunomius’ calumnious charge that the great Basil had said
that “man was emptied to become man,” and demonstrates that the “emptying” of the Only-
begotten took place with a view to the restoration to life of the Man Who had suffered726.
He asserts that we say that man has emptied Himself to become man, and that He Who
by obedience humbled Himself to the form of the servant shared the form of men even before
He took that form. No change has been made in the wording; we have simply transferred
the very words from his speech to our own. Now if there is anything of this sort in our
writings, (for I call my master’s writings ours) let no one blame our orator for calumny. I
ask for all regard for the truth: and we ourselves will give evidence. But if there is nothing
of all this in our writings, while his language not merely lays blame upon us, but is indignant
and wrathful as if the matter were clearly proved, calling us full of absurdity, nonsense,
confusion, inconsistency, and so on, I am at a loss to see the right course to take. Just as men
who are perplexed at the groundless rages of madmen can decide upon no plan to follow,
so I myself can find no device to meet this perplexity. Our master says (for I will again recite
his argument verbally), “He is not setting forth to us the mode of the Divine existence, but
the terms which belong to the Incarnation.” Our accuser starts from this point, and says
that we maintain that man emptied Himself to become man! What community is there
between one statement and the other? If we say that the Apostle has not set forth to us the
mode of the Divine existence, but points by his phrase to the dispensation of the Passion,
we are on this ground charged with speaking of the “emptying” of man to become man, and
with saying that the “form of the servant” had pretemporal existence, and that the Man Who
was born of Mary existed before the coming in the flesh! Well, I think it superfluous to
spend time in discussing what is admitted, seeing that truth itself frees us from the charge.
In a case, indeed, where one may have given the calumniators some handle against oneself,
it is proper to resist accusers: but where there is no danger of being suspected of some absurd
charge, the accusation becomes a proof, not of the false charge made against him who is
calumniated, but of the madness of the accuser. As, however, in dealing with the charge of
being ashamed of the Cross, we showed by our examination that the charge recoiled upon
the accuser, so we shall show how this charge too returns upon those who make it, since it
is they, and not we, who lay down the doctrine of the change of the Son from like to like in
179
the dispensation of the Passion. We will examine briefly, bringing them side by side, the
statements of each party. We say that the Only-begotten God, having by His own agency
726 This seems to be the sense of the Greek title. The Latin version of the earlier editions appears to represent
a different reading, “contigisse, quando in passione homo Christus passus est.”
He shows the falsehood of Eunomius' calumnious charge that the great Basil had said that “man was emptied to become man,” and demonstrates that the “emptying” of the Only-begotten took place with a view to the restoration to life of the Man Who had suffered.
342
He shows the falsehood of Eunomius' calumnious charge that the great Basil…