Edwards discovered it.” But if I was the first discoverer, he should have owned, that since I
have discovered it, he himself, and all my opposers, have seen cause to follow me, and receive
my discovery. For so the case seems to be, if he gives us a true account (in p. 132. b.) where
he rejects, with indignation, the imputation of any other opinion. “How often (says he) has
Mr. Edwards said, none but visible saints are to be admitted? Do not all Mr. Edwards’s op-
posers say, that no man is to be admitted, who does not profess his hearty belief of the gospel,
and the earnest and sincere purpose of his heart, so far as he knows it, to obey all God’s
commands, and keep his covenant? None, who do not make as full and express a profession
as the Israelites did, or was ever required by Christ or his apostles, in any instances that can
be produced in the Bible, of bodies of men or particular persons admitted into visible cov-
enant with God?”—He had before spoken of the words which the Israelites used in their
entering into covenant with God. (p. 5. d.) Which must refer to their entering into covenant
in the wilderness; for we have no account of any words at all used by that nation, at their
entering into covenant, if not there. And this he sometimes speaks of as the covenant they
made, when God took them into covenant. (p. 8. d. 36. d. e. 37. a. b.) And (p. 20.) he allows
that to be an instance of explicit covenanting: but ridicules my pretending to show, that ex-
plicit covenanting was a divine institution for all; when, he says, we have an account of but
four instances of any explicit covenanting with God by the Jews, and those on most extraordin-
ary occasions, and by the body of the people. But what matter is it, whether there were four,
or but two, or only that one instance in the wilderness? when he himself with such earnestness
declares, that all my opposers hold, every man must make as full and express a profession
of the covenant as ever the Israelites did, or was ever required, in any instance that can be
produced in the Bible, whether of bodies of men or particular persons’ admission, &c. If this
be so, and what he said before be also true, then all Israel, even every individual person
among them, that ever was admitted to the privileges of the church, throughout all their
generations, by his own confession and assertion, did personally make as explicit a profession
of the covenant, as the body of the people did in that instance in the wilderness. And not
only so, but the same must every individual person do, that ever comes to sacraments,
through all ages, to the end of the world.—Thus Mr. W. fights hard to beat down himself.
But I will not say in his own language, that in so doing he fights hard to beat down a poor
man of straw.
If any should say, that Mr. W. when speaking of an express profession, does not mean a
profession in words, but only in actions; such as an outward attendance on ordinances and
duties of worship: I answer, if such actions are a profession, yet certainly they are not an
express profession; they are no more than an implicit profession. And besides, it is very plain,
the profession he speaks of is a profession in words. Thus (p. 36. b.) when describing the
profession which ought to be made, he says, “It is in as strong words, as were used by any
whom the apostles admitted.” And elsewhere (as was before noted) he often insists, that a
1958
SECTION IX. Public covenanting.