Chapter VIII.—If It Be Granted that Second Marriage is Lawful, Yet All Things Lawful
are Not Expedient.
Let it now be granted that repetition of marriage is lawful, if everything which is lawful
is good. The same apostle exclaims: “All things are lawful, but all are not profitable.” 546
Pray, can what is “not profitable” be called good? If even things which do not make for
salvation are “lawful,” it follows that even things which are not good are “lawful.” But what
will it be your duty rather to choose; that which is good because it is “lawful,” or that which
is so because it is “profitable?” A wide difference I take to exist between “licence” and salva-
tion. Concerning the “good” it is not said “it is lawful;” inasmuch as “good” does not expect
to be permitted, but to be assumed. But that is “permitted” about which a doubt exists
55
whether it be “good;” which may likewise not be per mitted, if it have not some first (extrinsic)
cause of its being:—inasmuch as it is on account of the danger of incontinence that second
marriage, (for instance), is permitted:—because, unless the “licence” of some not (absolutely)
good thing were subject (so our choice), there were no means of proving who rendered a
willing obedience to the Divine will, and who to his own power; which of us follows
presentiality, and which embraces the opportunity of licence. “Licence,” for the most part,
is a trial of discipline; since it is through trial that discipline is proved, and through “licence”
that trial operates. Thus it comes to pass that “all things are lawful, but not all are expedient,”
so long as (it remains true that) whoever has a “permission” granted is (thereby) tried, and
is (consequently) judged during the process of trial in (the case of the particular) “permis-
sion.” Apostles, withal, had a “licence” to marry, and lead wives about (with them 547).
They had a “licence,” too, to “live by the Gospel.” 548 But he who, when occasion required,
549 “did not use this right,” provokes us to imitate his own example; teaching us that our
probation consists in that wherein “licence” has laid the groundwork for the experimental
proof of abstinence.
546 1 Cor. x. 23.
547 See 1 Cor. ix. 5.
548 See vers. 4, 9–18.
549 In occasionem.
If It Be Granted that Second Marriage is Lawful, Yet All Things Lawful are Not Expedient.
123
If It Be Granted that Second Marriage is Lawful, Yet All Things Lawful are…