Chapter XXXI.
Yet, even in their reply to this, or the like, they are not at a loss for a contentious rejoin-
der. For they assert that God, if He had been so pleased, might have forcibly drawn those,
who were not inclined to yield, to accept the Gospel message. But where then would have
been their free will? Where their virtuous merit? Where their meed of praise from their
moral directors? It belongs only to inanimate or irrational creatures to be brought round
by the will of another to his purpose; whereas the reasoning and intelligent nature, if it lays
aside its freedom of action, loses at the same time the gracious gift of intellect. For upon
what is he to employ any faculty of thought, if his power of choosing anything according to
his inclination lies in the will of another? But then, if the will remains without the capacity
of action, virtue necessarily disappears, since it is shackled by the enforced quiescence of
the will. Then, if virtue does not exist, life loses its value, reason moves in accordance with
fatalism, the praise of moral guardians2011 is gone, sin may be indulged in without risk, and
the difference between the courses of life is obliterated. For who, henceforth, could with any
reason condemn profligacy, or praise sobriety? Since2012 every one would have this ready
answer, that nothing of all the things we are inclined to is in our own power, but that by
some superior and ruling influence the wills of men are brought round to the purpose of
one who has the mastery over them. The conclusion, then is that it is not the goodness of
God that is chargeable with the fact that the Faith is not engendered in all men, but rather
the disposition of those by whom the preaching of the Word is received.
2011 τῶν κατορθούντων
2012 This is an answer to modern “Ethical Determinants.”
Chapter XXXI
937
Chapter XXXI