aware of the meaning of these words and contend against our statement. For if any one ex-
amines the words carefully, he will find that there is no mutual conflict between what is said
by us and what is said by him. For we both consider the dispensation in the flesh apart, and
regard the Divine power in itself: and he, in like manner with ourselves, says that the Word
that was in the beginning has been manifested in the flesh: yet no one ever charged him,
nor does he charge himself, with preaching “two Words”, Him Who was in the beginning,
and Him Who was made flesh; for he knows, surely, that the Word is identical with the
Word, He who appeared in the flesh with Him Who was with God. But the flesh was not
identical with the Godhead, till this too was transformed to the Godhead, so that of necessity
one set of attributes befits God the Word, and a different set of attributes befits the “form
of the servant732.” If, then, in view of such a confession, he does not reproach himself with
the duality of Words, why are we falsely charged with dividing the object of our faith into
“two Christs”?—we, who say that He Who was highly exalted after His Passion, was made
Lord and Christ by His union733 with Him Who is verily Lord and Christ, knowing by what
we have learnt that the Divine Nature is always one and the same, and with the same mode
of existence, while the flesh in itself is that which reason and sense apprehend concerning
it, but when mixed734 with the Divine no longer remains in its own limitations and properties,
but is taken up to that which is overwhelming and transcendent. Our contemplation, how-
ever, of the respective properties of the flesh and of the Godhead remains free from confusion,
so long as each of these is contemplated by itself735, as, for example, “the Word was before
the ages, but the flesh came into being in the last times”: but one could not reverse this
statement, and say that the latter is pretemporal, or that the Word has come into being in
the last times. The flesh is of a passible, the Word of an operative nature: and neither is the
732 This statement would seem to imply that, at some time after the Incarnation, the Humanity of Christ was
transformed to the Divine Nature, and made identical with It. From other passages in what has preceded, it
would seem that this change in the mutual relation of the two Natures might, according to the words of S.
Gregory, be conceived as taking place after the Passion. Thus it might be said that S. Gregory conceived the
union of the two Natures to be, since the Passion (or, more strictly, since the “exaltation”), what the Monophysites
conceived it to be from the moment of the Incarnation. But other phrases, again, seem to show that he conceived
the two Natures still to remain distinct (see note 4 inf.). There is, however, ample justification in S. Gregory’s
language for the remark of Bp. Hefele, that S. Gregory “cannot entirely free himself from the notion of a trans-
mutation of the Human Nature into the Divine.” (Hefele, Hist. of the Councils, Eng. Trans. vol. iii. p. 4.)
733 ἑνωσέως.
734 ἀνακραθεῖσα πρὸς τὸ θεῖον.
735 Here S. Gregory seems to state accurately the differentiation of the two Natures, while he recognizes the
possibility of the communicatio idiomatum: but it is not clear that he would acknowledge that the two Natures
still remain distinct. Even this, however, seems to be implied in his citation of Phil. ii. 11, at a later point.
346
Thereafter he shows that there are not two Christs or two Lords, but one…