Testimonia

Publiek archief van verzamelde en verwerkte bronrecords.
Overzicht / Records / record

native_whole_paragraph

Technische verwerking bevestigt geen inhoudelijke beoordeling of toestemming voor openbare publicatie.

record_key: e8eb5b11a5a6af72113e29439d0e01599ddf74d19973181775442ed0cc5e9f5f
origineel ID: xml-native:bd625a0fa4f5ddd4b2fa13fcee753de8832ea4b316625e0e06454beb81cfa652:979dcaed3e1d206b40d3fbf06bcaef234ec63a3ad3642b3520ebcebeeb41dcb2 · verwerkingsstatus: Verwerkt, inhoudelijk nog niet beoordeeld · teksthash: 141a7c7f230dca8b428330b301aee90165f25e65600e25090895d39095d4124d · 7,666 tekens

Tekst tekstblob openen

The first part only (see Table infra) of the letter is devoted to the history He undertakes to tell ἅπερ ἑ& 240·ρακα καὶ ἔγνων ἀκριβῶς, words which have given rise to the romantic but ill-founded tradition that, ubiquitious and untiring in his exile, he was a secret spectator of the proceedings of his enemies at these distant gatherings. (So Gibbon and, as far as Seleucia is concerned, Tillemont. Montfaucon, as usual, takes the more sober and likely view.) of the twin councils. Athanasius is probably mistaken in ascribing the movement for a great council to the Acacian or Homœan anxiety to eclipse and finally set aside the Council of Nicæa. The Semi-Arians, who were ill at ease and anxious to dissociate themselves from the growing danger of Anomœanism, and who at this time had the ear of Constantius, were the persons who desired a doctrinal settlement. It was the last effort of Eastern ‘Conservatism’ (yet see Gwatkin, Studies, p. 163) to formulate a position which without admitting the obnoxious ὁμοούσιον should yet condemn Arianism, conciliate the West, and restore peace to the Christian world. The failure of the attempt, gloomy and ignominious as it was, was yet the beginning of the end, the necessary precursor of the downfall of Arianism as a power within the Church. The cause of this failure is to be found in the intrigues of the Homœans, Valens in the West, Eudoxius and Acacius in the East. Nicæa was chosen by Constantius for the venue of the great Synod. But Basil, then in high favour, suggested Nicomedia, and thither the bishops were summoned. Before they could meet, the city was destroyed by an earthquake, and the venue was changed to Nicæa again. Now the Homœans saw their opportunity. Their one chance of escaping disaster was in the principle ‘divide et impera.’ The Council was divided into two: the Westerns were to meet at Ariminum, the Easterns at Seleucia in Cilicia, a place with nothing to recommend it excepting the presence of a strong military force. Hence also the conference of Homœan and Semi-Arian bishops at Sirmium, who drew up in the presence of Constantius, on Whitsun-Eve, the famous ‘dated’ or ‘third Sirmian’ Creed. Its wording (ὅμοιου κατὰ πάντα) shows the predominant influence of the Semi-Arians, in spite of the efforts of Valens to get rid of the test words, upon which the Emperor insisted. Basil moreover issued a separate memorandum to explain the sense in which he signed the creed, emphasising the absolute likeness of the Son to the Father (Bright, Introd., lxxxiii., Gwatkin, pp. 168 sq.), and accepting the Nicene doctrine in everything but the name. But for all Basil might say, the Dated Creed by the use of the word ὅμοιον had opened the door to any evasion that an Arian could desire: for ὅμοιον is a relative term admitting of degrees: what is only ‘like’ is ipso facto to some extent unlike (see below, §53). The party of Basil, then, entered upon the decisive contest already outmanœuvred, and doomed to failure. The events which followed are described by Athanasius (§§8–12). At Ariminum the Nicene, at Seleucia the Semi-Arian cause carried all before it. The Dated Creed, rejected with scorn at Ariminum, was unsuccessfully propounded in an altered form by Acacius at Seleucia. The rupture between Homœans and Semi-Arians was complete. So far only does Athanasius carry his account of the Synods: at this point he steps in with a fresh blow at the link which united Eastern Conservatism with the mixed multitude of original Arians like Euzoius and Valens, ultra Arians like Aetius and Eunomius, and Arianising opportunists like Acacius, Eudoxius, and their tribe. In the latter he recognises deadly foes who are to be confuted and exposed without any thought of compromise; in the former, brethren who misunderstand their own position, and whom explanation will surely bring round to their natural allies. In this twofold aim the de Synodis stands in the lines of the great anti-Arian discourses (supra, p. 304). But with the eye of a general Athanasius suits his attack to the new position. With the Arians, he has done with theological argument; he points indignantly to their intrigues and their brow-beating, to their lack of consistent principle, their endless synods and formularies (§§21–32); concisely he exposes the hollowness of their objection to the Nicene formula, the real logical basis upon which their position rests (§33–40, see Bright, xc.–xcii.). But to the Semi-Arians he turns with a serious and carefully stated vindication of the ὁμοούσιον. The time has come to press it earnestly upon them as the only adequate expression of what they really mean, as the only rampart which can withstand the Arian invasion. This, the last portion (§§41–54) of the letter, is the raison d’être of the whole: the account of the Synods is merely a means to this end, not his main purpose; the exposure of Arian principles and of Arian variations subserves the ultimate aim of detaching from them those of whom Athanasius was now hoping better things. It may be said that he over-rated the hopefulness of affairs as far as the immediate future was concerned. The weak acceptance by the Seleucian majority (or rather by their delegates) of the Arian creed of Niké, the triumph of Acacius, Eudoxius and their party as Constantius drifted in the last two years of his life nearer and nearer to ultra-Arianism (de Syn. 30, 31, his rupture with Basil, Theodt. ii. 27), the ascendancy of Arianism under Valens, and the eventual consolidation of a Semi-Arian sect under the name of Macedonius, all this at the first glance is a sad commentary upon the hopefulness of the de Synodis. But (1) even if this were all the truth, Athanasius was right: he was acting a noble part. In the de Synodis ‘even Athanasius rises above himself.’ Driven to bay by the pertinacity of his enemies, exasperated as we see him in the de Fuga and Arian History, ‘yet no sooner is he cheered with the news of hope than the importunate jealousies of forty years are hushed (contrast Ep. Æg. 7) in a moment, as though the Lord had spoken peace to the tumult of the grey old exile’s troubled soul’ (Gwatkin, Studies, p. 176, Arian Controv., p. 98). The charity that hopeth all things is always justified of her works. (2) Athanasius, however, was right in his estimate of the position. Not only did many of the Semi-Arians (e.g. the fifty-nine in 365) accept the ὁμοούσιον, but it was from the ranks of the Semi-Arians that the men arose who led the cause of Nicæa to its ultimate victory in the East. There accompanied Basil of Ancyra from the Seleucian Synod to Constantinople a young deacon and ascetic, who read and welcomed the appeal of Athanasius. Writing a few months later, this young theologian, Basil of Cæsarea, adopts the words of the de Synodis: ‘one God we confess, one in nature not in number, for number belongs to the category of quantity,…neither Like nor Unlike, for these terms belong to the category of quality (cf. below, §53)…He that is essentially God is Coessential with Him that is essentially God.…If I am to state my own opinion, I accept “Like in essence” with the addition of “exactly” as identical in sense with “Coessential”…but “exactly like” [without “essence”] I suspect.…Accordingly since “Coessential” is the term less open to abuse, on this ground I too adopt it’ (Epp. 8, 9, the Greek in Gwatkin, Studies, p. 242) Observe also that the Semi-Arian document of reconciliation in 363 (Socr. iii. 25) adopts the point pressed in de Syn. 41.. Basil the Great is, not indeed the only, but the conspicuous and abundant justification of the insight of Athanasius in the de Synodis.

Versies (1)

Versie 587171cfcddb7a47beb668625e2dc47136367e377fd92d2d94a7c3707fef4005
{"attributes_original":[["class","c12"],["id","xxii.i-p5"]],"namespaces_in_scope":{},"native_ancestor_context":{"$context_sha256":"9a0dd3a81daae80dc51cbb244a8b7cad812499babb638d7921ddaca4a3a92e72"},"native_charParams_count":0,"native_id":"xxii.i-p5","native_note_number":null,"native_page_context":null,"native_parent_unit_xpath":null,"native_role":"native_whole_paragraph","native_tag":"p","native_word_count":0,"reading_recipe":"native_mixed_character_data_order","source_byte_end":4079095,"source_byte_start":4070437,"source_document_context":{"adapter":"xml-native-whole-unit-v1","external_DTD_network_fetches":0,"native_header_xml":[{"$text_sha256":"614b20a6d071de5e43c393dd489dc1763aef916b253d64532e905918ef3145e0"}],"root_original":{"attributes_original":[],"qname":"ThML"},"source_encoding":"utf-8","source_prolog_original":{"$text_sha256":"6b04f7e2c423acb54df231fd2be2fd4cb7d4360e848b2d753f9253231aba3115"},"source_sha256":"bd625a0fa4f5ddd4b2fa13fcee753de8832ea4b316625e0e06454beb81cfa652","source_size":5809854},"source_encoding":"utf-8","source_fragment_bytes_sha256":"0f78670ee3313fe554f3aaa0395d8c215c2968741ae319ab6479f3999fdb8b97","source_sha256":"bd625a0fa4f5ddd4b2fa13fcee753de8832ea4b316625e0e06454beb81cfa652","source_size":5809854,"source_xml":{"$text_sha256":"0f78670ee3313fe554f3aaa0395d8c215c2968741ae319ab6479f3999fdb8b97"},"source_xml_utf8_sha256":"0f78670ee3313fe554f3aaa0395d8c215c2968741ae319ab6479f3999fdb8b97","source_xpath":"/ThML[1]/ThML.body[1]/div1[22]/div2[1]/p[5]"}

references: [] | work_id: | origin: source-native-xml | source:

Plaatsingen (1)

OrdinalInputVersie
/ThML[1]/ThML.body[1]/div1[22]/div2[1]/p[5]15992587171cfcddb7a47beb668625e2dc47136367e377fd92d2d94a7c3707fef4005

Bijbelverwijzingen (0)

CoördinaatReferentie

Live-status (1)

Live IDStatusMatchesSchema
xml-native:bd625a0fa4f5ddd4b2fa13fcee753de8832ea4b316625e0e06454beb81cfa652:979dcaed3e1d206b40d3fbf06bcaef234ec63a3ad3642b3520ebcebeeb41dcb2processed_not_found_in_observed_live0