11. You laugh because in ancient times the Persians worshipped rivers, as is told in the
writings which hand down these things to memory; the Arabians an unshapen stone;4642
the Scythian nations a sabre; the Thespians a branch instead of Cinxia;4643 the Icarians4644
an unhewn log instead of Diana; the people of Pessinus a flint instead of the mother of the
gods; the Romans a spear instead of Mars, as the muses of Varro point out; and, before they
511
were acquainted with the statuary’s art, the Samians a plank4645 instead of Juno, as Aëthli-
us4646 relates: and you do not laugh when, instead of the immortal gods, you make supplic-
ation to little images of men and human forms—nay, you even suppose that these very little
images are gods, and besides these you do not believe that anything has divine power. What
say you, O ye—! Do the gods of heaven have ears, then, and temples, an occiput, spine, loins,
sides, hams, buttocks, houghs,4647 ankles, and the rest of the other members with which we
have been formed, which were also mentioned in the first part of this book4648 a little more
fully, and cited with greater copiousness of language? Would that it were possible4649 to
look into the sentiments and very recesses of your mind, in which you revolve various and
enter into the most obscure considerations: we should find that you yourselves even feel as
we do, and have no other opinions as to the form of the deities. But what can we do with
obstinate prejudices? what with those who are menacing us with swords, and devising new
punishments against us? In your rage4650 you maintain a bad cause, and that although you
4642 It is worthy of notice that although in this passage, as often elsewhere, Arnobius adheres pretty closely
to the argument proposed by Clemens Alexandrinus, he even in such passages sometimes differs from it, and
not at random. Thus Clement speaks merely of a “stone,” and Arnobius of an “unshaped stone.” The former
expression harmonizes with the words of Maximus Tyrius (Serm., xxxviii. p. 225, Steph.), “The Arabians worship
I know not whom, but the image which I saw was a square stone;” while Suidas (Küster’s ed., s.v. θεὺς ῎Αρης)
agrees with Arnobius in calling it a “stone, black, square, unfashioned” (ἀτύπωτος). This is the more noteworthy,
as at times Arnobius would almost seem to be following Clement blindly. [See Clement, cap. iv. vol. ii. p. 184,
this series.]
4643 So Arnobius renders Clement’s Cithæronian Hera.
4644 So corrected in the notes of Canterus from Clem. for the ms. reading Carios, retained by the first four
edd. and Elmenh. In Icaria there was a temple of Diana called Ταυροπόλιον.
4645 The ms. and first four edd. read p-uteum—“a well,” corrected plut., as above, by Gifanius, and in the
notes of Canterus.
4646 The ms. reads ethedius, corrected in the notes of Canterus.
4647 So all edd., except both Roman edd., which retain the ms. reading in the singular, suffraginem.
4648 i. e., iii. 13. p. 467.
4649 Lit., “it was allowed.”
4650 So Meursius suggested amentes for the ms. reading animantis for which Heraldus proposed argu-
mentis—“by arguments.”
Chapter XI.
1238
Chapter XI.