But how do these things consist with reason, or with the word of God? Which represents,
that all God’s works, all that he has ever to do, the whole scheme and series of his operations,
are from the beginning perfectly in his view; and declares, that whatever devices and designs
are in the hearts of men, “the counsel of the Lord shall stand, and the thoughts of his heart
to all generations,” (Prov. xix. 21. Psal. xxxiii. 10, 11.) And “that which the Lord of hosts
hath purposed, none shall disannul,” Isa. xiv. 27.) And that he cannot be frustrated in one
design or thought, (Job xlii. 2.) And “that which God doth, it shall be for ever, that nothing
can be put to it, or taken from it,” (Eccl. iii. 14.) The stability and perpetuity of God’s
counsels are expressly spoken of as connected with his foreknowledge, (Isa. xlvi. 10.) “De-
claring the end from the beginning, and from ancient times the things that are not yet done;
saying, My counsel shall stand, and I will do my pleasure.”—And how are these things
consistent with what the Scripture says of God’s immutability, which represents him as
“without variableness, or shadow of turning;” and speaks of him, most particularly, as un-
changeable with regard to his purposes, (Mal. iii. 6.) “I am the Lord; I change not; therefore
ye sons of Jacob are not consumed.” (Exod. iii. 14.) “i am that i am.” (Job xxiii. 13, 14.) He
is in one mind; and who can turn him? And what his soul desireth, even that he doth: for
he performeth the thing that is appointed for me.”
ARG. V. If this notion of God’s ignorance of future Volitions of moral Agents be thor-
oughly considered in its consequences, it will appear to follow from it, that God, after he
had made the world, was liable to be wholly frustrated of his end in the creation of it; and
so has been, in like manner, liable to be frustrated of his end in all the great works he had
wrought. It is manifest, the moral world is the end of the natural: the rest of the creation is
but a house which God hath built, with furniture, for moral Agents: and the good or bad
state of the moral world depends on the improvement they make of their natural Agency,
and so depends on their Volitions. And therefore, if these cannot be foreseen by God, because
they are contingent, and subject to no kind of necessity, then the affairs of the moral world
are liable to go wrong, to any assignable degree; yea, liable to be utterly ruined. As on this
scheme, it may well be supposed to be literally said, when mankind, by the abuse of their
moral Agency, became very corrupt before the flood, ” that the Lord repented that he had
made man on the earth, and it grieved him at his heart;” so, when he made the universe, he
did not know but that he might be so disappointed in it, that it might grieve him at his heart
that he had made it. It actually proved, that all mankind became sinful, and a very great part
of the angels apostatized: and how could God know before, that all of them would not? And
how could God know but that all mankind, notwithstanding means used to reclaim them,
being still left to the freedom of their own Will, would continue in their apostasy, and grow
worse and worse, as they of the old world before the flood did?
According to the scheme I am endeavouring to confute, the fall of neither men nor angels
could be foreseen, and God must be greatly disappointed in these events; and so the grand
605
SECTION XI. The evidence of God's certain Foreknowledge of the Volitions…