Thus a propensity, attending the present nature or natural state of mankind, eternally
to ruin themselves by sin, may certainly be inferred from apparent and acknowledged
fact.—And I would now observe further, that not only does this follow from facts acknow-
ledged by Dr. T. but the things he asserts, and the expressions which he uses, plainly imply
that all mankind have such a propensity; yea, one of the highest kind, a propensity that is
invincible, or a tendency which really amounts to a fixed, constant, unfailing necessity. There
is a plain confession of a propensity or proneness to sin, p. 143.—“Man, who drinketh in
iniquity like water; who is attended with so many sensual appetites, and so APT to indulge
them.”—And again, p. 228. “we are very apt, in a world full of temptation, to be deceived,
and drawn into sin by bodily appetites.” If we are very apt or prone to be drawn into sin by
bodily appetites, and sinfully to indulge them, and very apt or prone to yield to temptation
to sin, then we are prone to sin; for to yield to temptation to sin is sinful.—In the same page
he shows, that on this account, and its consequences, the case of those who are under a law,
threatening death for every sin, must be quite deplorable, if they have no relief from the mercy
of the lawgiver. Which implies, that their case is hopeless, as to an escape from death, the
punishment of sin, by any other means than God’s mercy. And that implies such an aptness
to yield to temptation, as renders it hopeless that any of mankind should wholly avoid it.
But he speaks of it elsewhere, over and over, as truly impossible, or what cannot be; as in the
words before cited in the last section, from his note on Rom. v. 20. where he repeatedly
speaks of the law, which subjects us to death for every transgression, as what cannot give
life; and states, that if God offered us no other way of salvation, no man from the beginning
of the world could be saved. In the same place he cites with approbation Mr. Locke’s words,
in which, speaking of the Israelites, he says, “All endeavors after righteousness was lost labour,
since any one slip forfeited life, and it was impossible for them to expect ought but death.”
Our author speaks of it as impossible for the law requiring sinless obedience to give life, not
that the law was weak in itself, but through the weakness of our flesh. Therefore he says, he
conceives the law not to be a dispensation suitable to the infirmity of the human nature in its
present state. These things amount to a full confession, that the proneness in men to sin, and
to a demerit of and just exposedness to eternal ruin, is universally invincible; or, which is
event. But the thing we are speaking of, is a fixed cause: propensity is a stated continued thing. We justly agree,
that a stated effect must have a stated cause, and truly observe, that we obtain the notion of tendency, or stated
preponderation in causes, no other way than by observing a stated prevalence of a particular kind of effect. But
who ever argues a fixed propensity from a single event? And is it not strange arguing, that because an event
which once comes to pass, does not prove any stated tendency, therefore the unfailing constancy of an event is
an evidence of no such thing? But because Dr. T. makes so much of this objection from Adam sinning without
a propensity, I shall hereafter consider it more particularly, in the beginning of the 9th section of this chapter;
where will also be considered what is objected from the fall of the angels.
945
SECTION II. Universal sin proves a sinful propensity.