THE PREFACE.
Since I have been so repeatedly charged by Mr. Williams with indecent and injurious
treatment of Mr. Stoddard, (whom doubtless I ought to treat with much respect,) I may ex-
pect, from what appears of Mr. Williams’s disposition this way, to be charged with ill treat-
ment of him too. I desire therefore that it may be justly considered by the reader, what is,
and what is not, injurious or unhandsome treatment of an author in a controversy. And
here I would crave leave to say, that I humbly conceive, a distinction ought to be made
between opposing and exposing a cause, or the arguments used to defend it, and reproaching
persons. He is a weak writer indeed, who undertakes to confute an opinion, but dares not
expose the nakedness and absurdity of it, nor the weakness or inconsistence of the methods
taken and arguments used by any to maintain it, for fear he should be guilty of speaking
evil of these things, and be charged with reproaching them. If an antagonist is angry at this,
he thereby gives his readers too much occasion of suspicion towards himself, as chargeable
with weakness, or bitterness.
I therefore now give notice, that I have taken full liberty in this respect; only endeavouring
to avoid pointed and exaggerating expressions. If to set forth what I suppose to be the true
absurdity of Mr. Williams’s scheme, or any part of it, that it may be viewed justly in all its
nakedness; withal observing the weakness of the defence he has made, not fearing to show
wherein it is weak, and how the badness of his cause obliges him to be inconsistent with
himself, inconsistent with his own professed principles in religion, and with things conceded
and asserted by him in the book especially under consideration; and declaring particularly
wherein I think his arguments, fail whether it be in begging the question, or being impertinent
and beside the question, or arguing in effect against himself; also observing wherein Mr. W.
has made misrepresentations of words or things; I say, if to do these things be reproaching
him, and injurious treatment of him, then I have injured him.—But I think I should be
foolish, if I were afraid to do that (and to do it as thoroughly as I can) which must be the
design of my writing, if I write at all in opposition to his tenets, and to the defence he makes
of them.
Indeed if I misrepresent what he says, in order to make it appear in the worst colours;
altering his words to another sense, to make them appear more ridiculous; or adding other
words, that carry the sense beyond the proper import of his words, to heighten the supposed
absurdity, and give me greater advantage to exclaim; if I set myself to aggravate matters,
and strain them beyond bounds, making mighty things of mere trifles: or if I use exclamations
and invectives, instead of arguments; then Mr. W. might have just cause to complain, and
the reader would have just reason for disgust. But whether I have done so, or not, must be
judged by the reader; of whom I desire nothing more than the most impartial and exact
consideration of the merits of the cause, and examination of the force and weight of every
argument. I desire, that no bitter reproachful invectives, no vehement exclamations, no su-
Preface.
1895
Preface.