xiii
superior authority of the council was not only taught, but on one occasion acted on, by a
council, but this is outside of the period covered by the Seven Ecumenical Synods, and I
shall therefore only discuss the relations of these seven synods to the Roman See. And in
the first place it is evident that no council has ever been received as ecumenical which has
not been received and confirmed by the Roman Pontiff. But, after all, this is only saying
that no council has been accepted as ecumenical which has not been ecumenically received,
for it must be remembered that there was but one Patriarchate for the whole West, that of
Rome; and this is true to all intents and purposes, whether or no certain sections had ex-
trapatriarchal privileges, and were “auto-cephalous.”
But it would be giving an entirely unfair impression of the matter to the reader were he
left to suppose that this necessity for Rome’s confirmation sprang necessarily from any idea
of Rome’s infallibility. So far as appears from any extant document, such an idea was as
unknown in the whole world then as it is in four of the five patriarchates to-day. And it
should be borne in mind that the confirmation by the Emperor was sought for and spoken
of in quite as strong, if not stronger, terms. Before passing to a particular examination of
what relation each of the Councils bore to the Roman See, it may be well to note that while
as an historical fact each of the Seven Ecumenical Councils did eventually find acceptance
at Rome, this fact does not prove that such acceptance is necessary in the nature of things.
If we can imagine a time when Rome is not in communion with the greater part of the West,
then it is quite possible to imagine that an Ecumenical Council could be held whose decrees
would (for the time being) be rejected by the unworthy occupant of the Apostolic See. I am
not asserting that such a state of affairs is possible from a theological standpoint, but merely
stating an historical contingency which is perfectly within the range of imagination, even
if cut off from any practical possibility by the faith of some.
We now come to a consideration of how, by its acts, each of the Seven Synods intimated
its relation to the Roman See:
1. The First Council of Nice passed a canon in which some at least of the Roman rights
are evidently looked upon as being exactly on the same plane as those of other metropolitans,
declaring that they rest upon “custom.”
It was the Emperor who originated this council and called it together, if we may believe
his own words and those of the council; and while indeed it is possible that when the Em-
peror did not preside in person, Hosius of Cordova may have done so (even uniting the two
Roman Presbyters who were the legates of the Roman See with him), yet there is no evidence
that anything of the kind ever took place, and a pope, Felix III. (a.d. 483–492), in his Fifth
Epistle (ad Imp. Zen.) declares that Eustathius, bishop of Antioch, presided at this council.6
6 Cf. Theod. H. E., Lib. I., e. 6.
9
Concerning Ecumenical Councils in General.