VER. 18 — 23. ST. JOHN. 335
sayatonce,Whom ye made blind? They trytwo ways of
making them deny the miracle: by saying,Who yesaywas
born blind,and by adding,How then doth he now see?
THEOPHYL. Either,saythey,itisnottruethathe now sees,
or itisuntruethathe was blindbefore: but itisevident
thathe now sees; thereforeitisnot truethathe was born
blind. CHRYS. Threethingsthen being asked,— ifhe were
theirson,if he had been blind,and how he saw.— theyJi"'.1"'-' ' , j ]v1ii_2.
acknowledgetwo of them : His parentsansweredthem and
said,We know thatthisis our son,and thathe was born
blind.But the thirdtheyrefuseto speakto: But by what
means he now seeth,we know not. The enquiryinthisway
ends in confirmingthe truthof the miracle,by making it
restupon the incontrovertibleevidenceof the confessionof
the healedpersonhimself;He isofage,theysay,askhim;
he can speakfor himself.AUG. As ifto say,We mightAug.Tr.
justlybe compelledto speak foran infant,thatcouldnot '*.10"
speakforitself:but he, though blindfrom hisbirth,has
been alwaysabletospeak. CHRYS. What sortof gratitudeChrys.
isthisintheparents; concealingwhat theyknew, fromfearJJ°n^
of the Jews? as we are next told; Thesewords spakehis
parents,becausetheyfearedtheJews. And then the Evan
gelistmentionsagainwhat the intentionsand dispositions
of the Jews were: For the Jews had agreedalready,that
if any man did confessthat He was Christ,he shouldbe
putout of thesynagogue,AUO. It was no disadvantagetoAng.Tr.
be put out of the synagogue: whom theycastout,Christxliv-10.
tookin.
Thereforesaidhisparents,He isofaye,askhim. ALCUIN.
The Evangelistshews thatitwas not from ignorance,but
fear,thattheygavethisanswer. THEOPHYL. For theywere
fainthearted;not liketheirson,that intrepidwitnessto
the truth,the eyes of whose understandinghad been en
lightenedby God.
24. Then againcalledtheytheman thatwas blind,
and saidunto him, Give God the praise: we know
thatthisman isa sinner.
25. He answeredand said,Whether He be a sinner