VER. 3. ST. JOHN. 13
theSon. What can be more insanethan such language?
They argue,however,why was itnot saidthattheWord
made allthings,insteadofthe prepositionby1 beingused?1SA
Forthisreason,thatthou mightestnot understandan Un-
begotteuand UnoriginateSon,a rivalGodd. CHRYS. IftheChrya.
prepositionby perplexthee,and thou wouldestlearnfromjo°™'™
ScripturethattheWord Itselfmade allthings,hearDavid,[i»•]c.2-
Thou,Lord,in thebeginninghostlaidthefoundationof thePs.101.
earth,and the heavensare thework ofThy hands. That he
spokethisoftheOnly-Begotten,you learnfrom theApostle,
who intheEpistletotheHebrews appliesthesewordstothe
Son. CH&YS. But ifyou saythattheprophetspokethisofChrys.
theFather,and thatPaul appliedittotheSon,itcomes to"^'V'
thesame thing. For he would not have mentionedthatas
applicableto the Son, unlesshe fullyconsideredthatthe
Fatherand theSon were of equaldignity.If againthou
dreamthatin the preposition////any subjectionisimplied,
why doesPaul use itof theFather? as,God isfaithful,by \COv.
Whom ye were calledintothefellowshipof His Son; and ^'or
again,Paul an Apostleby thewillofGod. ORIGEN. Here 1,1.
tooValentinuserrs,saying,thattheWord suppliedto thea/a's.
Creatorthe causeof the creationof the worlde. If this
interpretationis true,itshouldhave been writtenthatall
thingshad theirexistencefrom theWord throughtheCrea
tor,notcontrariwise,throughtheWord from theCreator.
And withoutHim was not any thingmade.
CHRYS.That you may not suppose,when he says,All Chrys
thingswere made by Him, thathe meant only the thingsin^'J^'
Moses had spokenof,he seasonablybringsin,And without
Him was not any thingmade, nothing,thatis,cognizable
eitherby the senses,or the understanding.Or thus; Lest
you shouldsuspectthe sentence,All thingswere made by
Him,torefertothemiracleswhichtheotherEvangelistshad
related,he adds,and withoutHim was not any thingmade.
HILARY.Or thus;That allthingsweremade byHim, ispro-Hilar.nouncingtoomuch, itmay be said.Thereisau Uiibegotten|[£iii1i.cde8t
* The textof Aug. has " et Dei con- • rbv v^K afrttivirapf'xoiravTJSytvl-
ditotcm," perhaps it should be, 'et anas rov Roa^oS r<f8i)/iiovpy$.Origen
Deo cinitrariam,'(as before " Patri is speaking of Heracleon, a discipleof
conlrarium.")Tbeoph. has iajrlSfav. Valeniitms.